Example 1
Question: Mr. Ramesh Verma invested ₹18,000 when the market value (MV) of a share was ₹150. He sold 50 shares when the MV rose to ₹180 and sold the remaining shares when the MV fell to ₹120. He paid 0.2% brokerage on each transaction. Find whether he made a profit or a loss, and by how much.
Solution: Step 1 — Find the number of shares purchased. \nTotal investment = ₹18,000, MV at purchase = ₹150, brokerage = 0.2%. \nCost per share including brokerage: \[150 \times \left(1 + \frac{0.2}{100}\right) = 150 \times 1.002 = 150.30\] \nNumber of shares purchased: \[\frac{18000}{150.30} = 119.76 \approx 119 \text{ shares (taking whole shares)}\] \nActually, let us reinterpret: the face value is ₹150 per share and the investor invests ₹18,000 at MV ₹150 each, so number of shares = \[\frac{18000}{150} = 120 \text{ shares}\] \nStep 2 — Actual cost paid (with brokerage). \nBrokerage on purchase = 0.2% of total purchase cost: \[\text{Total purchase cost} = 120 \times 150 = 18000\] \[\text{Brokerage paid} = \frac{0.2}{100} \times 18000 = 36\] \nSo total cost price (CP) = ₹18,000 + ₹36 = ₹18,036. \nStep 3 — Sale proceeds for the first lot (50 shares at MV ₹180). \nGross sale value: \[50 \times 180 = 9000\] \nBrokerage deducted: \[\frac{0.2}{100} \times 9000 = 18\] \nNet sale proceeds (first lot) = ₹9,000 − ₹18 = ₹8,982. \nStep 4 — Sale proceeds for the second lot (remaining shares at MV ₹120). \nRemaining shares = 120 − 50 = 70 shares. \nGross sale value: \[70 \times 120 = 8400\] \nBrokerage deducted: \[\frac{0.2}{100} \times 8400 = 16.80\] \nNet sale proceeds (second lot) = ₹8,400 − ₹16.80 = ₹8,383.20. \nStep 5 — Total sale proceeds. \[8982 + 8383.20 = 17365.20\] \nStep 6 — Profit or Loss. \[\text{Total SP} - \text{Total CP} = 17365.20 - 18036 = -670.80\] \nSince the result is negative, Mr. Verma incurred a loss of ₹670.80.
Answer: Mr. Ramesh Verma made a loss of ₹670.80.
Example 2
Question: Ms. Priya Sharma invested ₹24,750 in shares when the market value (MV) was ₹225 per share. She sold 40 shares when the MV increased to ₹270 and sold the remaining shares when the MV dropped to ₹200. Brokerage was 0.5% on each transaction. Determine whether she made a profit or a loss and state the amount.
Solution: Step 1 — Find the number of shares purchased. \nInvestment = ₹24,750, MV at purchase = ₹225. \nNumber of shares: \[\frac{24750}{225} = 110 \text{ shares}\] \nStep 2 — Total cost including brokerage. \nGross purchase amount: \[110 \times 225 = 24750\] \nBrokerage paid (0.5%): \[\frac{0.5}{100} \times 24750 = 123.75\] \nTotal CP = ₹24,750 + ₹123.75 = ₹24,873.75. \nStep 3 — Sale proceeds for the first lot (40 shares at MV ₹270). \nGross sale value: \[40 \times 270 = 10800\] \nBrokerage deducted: \[\frac{0.5}{100} \times 10800 = 54\] \nNet proceeds (first lot) = ₹10,800 − ₹54 = ₹10,746. \nStep 4 — Sale proceeds for the second lot (remaining shares at MV ₹200). \nRemaining shares = 110 − 40 = 70 shares. \nGross sale value: \[70 \times 200 = 14000\] \nBrokerage deducted: \[\frac{0.5}{100} \times 14000 = 70\] \nNet proceeds (second lot) = ₹14,000 − ₹70 = ₹13,930. \nStep 5 — Total sale proceeds. \[10746 + 13930 = 24676\] \nStep 6 — Profit or Loss. \[\text{Total SP} - \text{Total CP} = 24676 - 24873.75 = -197.75\] \nSince the result is negative, Ms. Sharma incurred a loss of ₹197.75.
Answer: Ms. Priya Sharma made a loss of ₹197.75.