SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Problem Set 4A Q10 (i)

For the given trading chain prepare the tax invoice \(\text{I,II,III.}\) GST at the rate of \(12\%\) was charged for the article supplied.
Prepare the statement of GST payable under each head by the wholesaler, distributor and retailer at the time of filing the return to the government.

MAH STATE BOARD Mah SB Class 10 Maths · Financial Planning

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a toy passing from a factory to a shop to you. At every stop, a small extra charge called GST is added to the price. Each person in the chain keeps only the extra tax they added on top, not all the tax collected. The government gets a little bit from each person along the way. So by the time the toy reaches you, the total tax has been shared fairly among everyone who handled it.

Answer: Invoice I: GST = Rs. 600 (CGST 300 + SGST 300); Invoice II: GST = Rs. 720 (CGST 360 + SGST 360); Invoice III: GST = Rs. 780 (CGST 390 + SGST 390). GST payable to government: Wholesaler CGST Rs. 300, SGST Rs. 300; Distributor CGST Rs. 60, SGST Rs. 60; Retailer CGST Rs. 30, SGST Rs. 30.

📖 GST Trading Chain: Wholesaler, Distributor, Retailer

Detailed Explanation

In a GST trading chain, each dealer collects GST from the buyer (output tax) and pays GST to their supplier (input tax / ITC). At the time of filing the return, each dealer pays only the difference: Output tax minus Input Tax Credit (ITC). Since this is an intra-state supply, the total GST of 12% is split equally into CGST 6% and SGST 6%. The taxable values from the diagram are: Wholesaler = Rs. 5000, Distributor = Rs. 6000, Retailer = Rs. 6500.

Formula Used

GST payable = Output GST - Input Tax Credit (ITC); CGST = SGST = 6% of taxable value

Solution

  1. Step 1: Tax Invoice I (Wholesaler to Distributor): Taxable value = Rs. 5000, GST rate = 12% (CGST 6% + SGST 6%). \[ \text{CGST} = 6\% \text{ of } 5000 = \dfrac{6}{100} \times 5000 = 300 \] \[ \text{SGST} = 6\% \text{ of } 5000 = 300 \] \[ \text{Total GST} = 300 + 300 = 600 \] \[ \text{Invoice total} = 5000 + 600 = 5600 \]
  2. Step 2: Tax Invoice II (Distributor to Retailer): Taxable value = Rs. 6000. \[ \text{CGST} = 6\% \text{ of } 6000 = 360 \] \[ \text{SGST} = 6\% \text{ of } 6000 = 360 \] \[ \text{Total GST} = 720 \] \[ \text{Invoice total} = 6000 + 720 = 6720 \]
  3. Step 3: Tax Invoice III (Retailer to Consumer): Taxable value = Rs. 6500. \[ \text{CGST} = 6\% \text{ of } 6500 = 390 \] \[ \text{SGST} = 6\% \text{ of } 6500 = 390 \] \[ \text{Total GST} = 780 \] \[ \text{Invoice total} = 6500 + 780 = 7280 \]
  4. Step 4: GST payable by Wholesaler: The wholesaler is the first seller, so there is no input tax credit (ITC = 0). Output tax collected from distributor = CGST 300, SGST 300. \[ \text{CGST payable} = 300 - 0 = 300 \] \[ \text{SGST payable} = 300 - 0 = 300 \]
  5. Step 5: GST payable by Distributor: Output tax collected from retailer: CGST 360, SGST 360. ITC (paid to wholesaler): CGST 300, SGST 300. \[ \text{CGST payable} = 360 - 300 = 60 \] \[ \text{SGST payable} = 360 - 300 = 60 \]
  6. Step 6: GST payable by Retailer: Output tax collected from consumer: CGST 390, SGST 390. ITC (paid to distributor): CGST 360, SGST 360. \[ \text{CGST payable} = 390 - 360 = 30 \] \[ \text{SGST payable} = 390 - 360 = 30 \]
  7. Step 7: Statement of GST payable to Government: Wholesaler: CGST = Rs. 300, SGST = Rs. 300. Distributor: CGST = Rs. 60, SGST = Rs. 60. Retailer: CGST = Rs. 30, SGST = Rs. 30. Total CGST collected by government \[ = 300 + 60 + 30 = 390 \] Total SGST collected by government \[ = 300 + 60 + 30 = 390 \] which matches the final GST paid by the consumer (Rs. 780).

Final Answer

Invoice I: GST = Rs. 600 (CGST 300 + SGST 300); Invoice II: GST = Rs. 720 (CGST 360 + SGST 360); Invoice III: GST = Rs. 780 (CGST 390 + SGST 390). GST payable to government: Wholesaler CGST Rs. 300, SGST Rs. 300; Distributor CGST Rs. 60, SGST Rs. 60; Retailer CGST Rs. 30, SGST Rs. 30.

Common Mistake

Students often forget to subtract the Input Tax Credit (ITC) and pay the full output tax to the government. Remember, only the difference between output tax and ITC is actually payable at the time of filing the GST return.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the taxable values at each stage from the diagram: Wholesaler sells at Rs. 5000, Distributor sells at Rs. 6000, Retailer sells at Rs. 6500. The GST rate is 12%, split equally as CGST 6% and SGST 6% since this is an intra-state transaction. — Reason: Knowing the taxable value at each stage lets us calculate the GST on each invoice separately.
  2. Step 2: Calculate Tax Invoice I (Wholesaler to Distributor), taxable value = Rs. 5000. \[ \text{CGST} = \frac{6}{100} \times 5000 = 300 \] \[ \text{SGST} = \frac{6}{100} \times 5000 = 300 \] Total GST on Invoice I = \( 300 + 300 = 600 \), so the invoice amount = \( 5000 + 600 = 5600 \). — Reason: The wholesaler charges 12% GST on the price at which they sell, giving the first invoice total.
  3. Step 3: Calculate Tax Invoice II (Distributor to Retailer), taxable value = Rs. 6000. \[ \text{CGST} = \frac{6}{100} \times 6000 = 360 \] \[ \text{SGST} = \frac{6}{100} \times 6000 = 360 \] Total GST on Invoice II = \( 360 + 360 = 720 \), so the invoice amount = \( 6000 + 720 = 6720 \). — Reason: The distributor charges 12% GST on their selling price of Rs. 6000, generating the second invoice.
  4. Step 4: Calculate Tax Invoice III (Retailer to Consumer), taxable value = Rs. 6500. \[ \text{CGST} = \frac{6}{100} \times 6500 = 390 \] \[ \text{SGST} = \frac{6}{100} \times 6500 = 390 \] Total GST on Invoice III = \( 390 + 390 = 780 \), so the invoice amount = \( 6500 + 780 = 7280 \). — Reason: The retailer charges 12% GST on their selling price of Rs. 6500, completing all three invoices.
  5. Step 5: Find GST payable by the Wholesaler to the government. The wholesaler has no supplier in this chain, so ITC = Rs. 0. \[ \text{CGST payable} = 300 - 0 = 300 \] \[ \text{SGST payable} = 300 - 0 = 300 \] — Reason: Since the wholesaler did not pay any GST to a previous dealer, the entire output GST of Rs. 300 + Rs. 300 goes directly to the government.
  6. Step 6: Find GST payable by the Distributor to the government. The distributor's ITC = GST paid on Invoice I, i.e., CGST = Rs. 300 and SGST = Rs. 300. \[ \text{CGST payable} = 360 - 300 = 60 \] \[ \text{SGST payable} = 360 - 300 = 60 \] — Reason: The distributor subtracts the GST already paid to the wholesaler (ITC) from the GST collected from the retailer, paying only the net amount.
  7. Step 7: Find GST payable by the Retailer to the government. The retailer's ITC = GST paid on Invoice II, i.e., CGST = Rs. 360 and SGST = Rs. 360. \[ \text{CGST payable} = 390 - 360 = 30 \] \[ \text{SGST payable} = 390 - 360 = 30 \] — Reason: Similarly, the retailer offsets the GST paid to the distributor against the GST collected from the consumer, remitting only the incremental tax.
  8. Step 8: Verify the total GST received by the government equals the GST paid by the final consumer. Total CGST collected = \( 300 + 60 + 30 = 390 \), which matches the CGST on the final sale value of Rs. 6500. Total SGST collected = \( 300 + 60 + 30 = 390 \), which also matches. — Reason: This cross-check confirms that the ITC mechanism correctly distributes the tax burden across the chain without double-taxation.

Final Answer

Invoice I: GST = Rs. 600 (CGST 300 + SGST 300); Invoice II: GST = Rs. 720 (CGST 360 + SGST 360); Invoice III: GST = Rs. 780 (CGST 390 + SGST 390). GST payable to government: Wholesaler CGST Rs. 300, SGST Rs. 300; Distributor CGST Rs. 60, SGST Rs. 60; Retailer CGST Rs. 30, SGST Rs. 30.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students often calculate GST payable by each dealer on the full invoice value instead of subtracting the Input Tax Credit (ITC) — remember, each dealer pays GST only on the VALUE ADDED at their stage, not on the entire selling price.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Invoice I (Wholesaler → Distributor), Taxable Value = Rs. 5000: CGST = SGST =  6% of 5000  ⇒   \[\frac{6}{100} \times 5000 = 300\] Total GST =     \[300 + 300 = 600\]
  2. Invoice II (Distributor → Retailer), Taxable Value = Rs. 6000: CGST = SGST: \[\frac{6}{100} \times 6000 = 360\] Total GST: \[360 + 360 = 720\]
  3. Invoice III (Retailer → Consumer), Taxable Value = Rs. 6500: CGST = SGST: \[\frac{6}{100} \times 6500 = 390\] Total GST: \[390 + 390 = 780\]
  4. GST Payable to Government (Output GST − ITC): Wholesaler (ITC = 0): CGST = Rs. 300, SGST = Rs. 300. Distributor: CGST = \[360 - 300 = 60\] SGST = Rs. 60. Retailer: CGST = \[390 - 360 = 30\] SGST = Rs. 30.

Answer: Invoice I: GST = Rs. 600 (CGST 300 + SGST 300); Invoice II: GST = Rs. 720 (CGST 360 + SGST 360); Invoice III: GST = Rs. 780 (CGST 390 + SGST 390). GST payable to government: Wholesaler CGST Rs. 300, SGST Rs. 300; Distributor CGST Rs. 60, SGST Rs. 60; Retailer CGST Rs. 30, SGST Rs. 30.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A manufacturer sells an article to a wholesaler for \(\rupee\,8{,}000\). The wholesaler sells it to a distributor for \(\rupee\,9{,}500\). The distributor sells it to a retailer for \(\rupee\,11{,}000\). The retailer sells it to a consumer for \(\rupee\,13{,}000\). GST is charged at \(18\%\) throughout the intra-state trading chain. Prepare a statement of GST payable under each head (CGST and SGST) by the wholesaler, distributor, and retailer when filing returns to the government.

Solution: GST rate is \(18\%\), so CGST \(= 9\%\) and SGST \(= 9\%\) on each transaction. \nStep 1 — Wholesaler's position: \nGST paid on purchase (Input Tax Credit): \[\text{Input GST} = 18\% \times 8000 = \frac{18}{100} \times 8000 = \rupee\,1440\]\nCGST paid \(= \rupee\,720\), SGST paid \(= \rupee\,720\). \nGST collected on sale (Output Tax): \[\text{Output GST} = 18\% \times 9500 = \frac{18}{100} \times 9500 = \rupee\,1710\]\nCGST collected \(= \rupee\,855\), SGST collected \(= \rupee\,855\). \nGST payable by wholesaler: \[\text{CGST payable} = 855 - 720 = \rupee\,135\] \[\text{SGST payable} = 855 - 720 = \rupee\,135\]\nTotal GST payable by wholesaler \(= \rupee\,270\). \nStep 2 — Distributor's position: \nGST paid on purchase (Input Tax Credit) = Output GST of wholesaler \(= \rupee\,1710\).\nCGST paid \(= \rupee\,855\), SGST paid \(= \rupee\,855\). \nGST collected on sale: \[\text{Output GST} = 18\% \times 11000 = \frac{18}{100} \times 11000 = \rupee\,1980\]\nCGST collected \(= \rupee\,990\), SGST collected \(= \rupee\,990\). \nGST payable by distributor: \[\text{CGST payable} = 990 - 855 = \rupee\,135\] \[\text{SGST payable} = 990 - 855 = \rupee\,135\]\nTotal GST payable by distributor \(= \rupee\,270\). \nStep 3 — Retailer's position: \nGST paid on purchase (Input Tax Credit) = Output GST of distributor \(= \rupee\,1980\).\nCGST paid \(= \rupee\,990\), SGST paid \(= \rupee\,990\). \nGST collected on sale: \[\text{Output GST} = 18\% \times 13000 = \frac{18}{100} \times 13000 = \rupee\,2340\]\nCGST collected \(= \rupee\,1170\), SGST collected \(= \rupee\,1170\). \nGST payable by retailer: \[\text{CGST payable} = 1170 - 990 = \rupee\,180\] \[\text{SGST payable} = 1170 - 990 = \rupee\,180\]\nTotal GST payable by retailer \(= \rupee\,360\).

Answer: Wholesaler: CGST \(= \rupee\,135\), SGST \(= \rupee\,135\) (Total \(= \rupee\,270\)). Distributor: CGST \(= \rupee\,135\), SGST \(= \rupee\,135\) (Total \(= \rupee\,270\)). Retailer: CGST \(= \rupee\,180\), SGST \(= \rupee\,180\) (Total \(= \rupee\,360\)).

Example 2

Question: In an intra-state trading chain, a manufacturer sells an article to a wholesaler for \(\rupee\,5{,}000\). The wholesaler sells it to a distributor for \(\rupee\,6{,}500\). The distributor sells it to a retailer for \(\rupee\,8{,}000\). GST is charged at \(5\%\) on every transaction. Prepare tax invoices and find the GST payable under each head (CGST and SGST) by the wholesaler, distributor, and retailer when filing returns to the government.

Solution: GST rate is \(5\%\), so CGST \(= 2.5\%\) and SGST \(= 2.5\%\) on each transaction. \nTax Invoice I — Manufacturer to Wholesaler: \nTaxable value \(= \rupee\,5000\). \[\text{CGST} = 2.5\% \times 5000 = \frac{2.5}{100} \times 5000 = \rupee\,125\] \[\text{SGST} = 2.5\% \times 5000 = \rupee\,125\]\nTotal invoice value \(= 5000 + 125 + 125 = \rupee\,5250\). \nTax Invoice II — Wholesaler to Distributor: \nTaxable value \(= \rupee\,6500\). \[\text{CGST} = 2.5\% \times 6500 = \frac{2.5}{100} \times 6500 = \rupee\,162.50\] \[\text{SGST} = 2.5\% \times 6500 = \rupee\,162.50\]\nTotal invoice value \(= 6500 + 162.50 + 162.50 = \rupee\,6825\). \nTax Invoice III — Distributor to Retailer: \nTaxable value \(= \rupee\,8000\). \[\text{CGST} = 2.5\% \times 8000 = \frac{2.5}{100} \times 8000 = \rupee\,200\] \[\text{SGST} = 2.5\% \times 8000 = \rupee\,200\]\nTotal invoice value \(= 8000 + 200 + 200 = \rupee\,8400\). \nGST payable by Wholesaler: \nInput GST (paid to manufacturer) \(= \rupee\,250\) (CGST \(= \rupee\,125\), SGST \(= \rupee\,125\)).\nOutput GST (collected from distributor) \(= \rupee\,325\) (CGST \(= \rupee\,162.50\), SGST \(= \rupee\,162.50\)). \[\text{CGST payable} = 162.50 - 125 = \rupee\,37.50\] \[\text{SGST payable} = 162.50 - 125 = \rupee\,37.50\]\nTotal GST payable by wholesaler \(= \rupee\,75\). \nGST payable by Distributor: \nInput GST (paid to wholesaler) \(= \rupee\,325\) (CGST \(= \rupee\,162.50\), SGST \(= \rupee\,162.50\)).\nOutput GST (collected from retailer) \(= \rupee\,400\) (CGST \(= \rupee\,200\), SGST \(= \rupee\,200\)). \[\text{CGST payable} = 200 - 162.50 = \rupee\,37.50\] \[\text{SGST payable} = 200 - 162.50 = \rupee\,37.50\]\nTotal GST payable by distributor \(= \rupee\,75\).

Answer: Wholesaler: CGST \(= \rupee\,37.50\), SGST \(= \rupee\,37.50\) (Total \(= \rupee\,75\)). Distributor: CGST \(= \rupee\,37.50\), SGST \(= \rupee\,37.50\) (Total \(= \rupee\,75\)).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A trading chain involves a Manufacturer, a Wholesaler, a Distributor, and a Retailer. GST is charged at the rate of 18% for the article supplied. The details are as follows: The Manufacturer sells to the Wholesaler at a price of Rs. 8000. The Wholesaler sells to the Distributor at a price of Rs. 9500. The Distributor sells to the Retailer at a price of Rs. 10200. Prepare Tax Invoice I (Wholesaler's purchase), Invoice II (Wholesaler's sale / Distributor's purchase), and Invoice III (Distributor's sale / Retailer's purchase). Also prepare the statement of GST payable under each head (CGST and SGST) by the Wholesaler, Distributor, and Retailer at the time of filing the return to the government.

Solution

  1. Step 1: GST on Invoice I (Manufacturer sells to Wholesaler at Rs. 8000): GST Rate = 18%. GST on Invoice I: \[\text{GST} = 8000 \times \frac{18}{100} = \text{Rs. } 1440\] This splits equally into CGST and SGST: \[\text{CGST} = \text{SGST} = \frac{1440}{2} = \text{Rs. } 720\] So Invoice I Total = Rs. 8000 + Rs. 1440 = Rs. 9440.
  2. Step 2: GST on Invoice II (Wholesaler sells to Distributor at Rs. 9500): GST on Invoice II: \[\text{GST} = 9500 \times \frac{18}{100} = \text{Rs. } 1710\] Splitting equally: \[\text{CGST} = \text{SGST} = \frac{1710}{2} = \text{Rs. } 855\] So Invoice II Total = Rs. 9500 + Rs. 1710 = Rs. 11210.
  3. Step 3: GST on Invoice III (Distributor sells to Retailer at Rs. 10200): GST on Invoice III: \[\text{GST} = 10200 \times \frac{18}{100} = \text{Rs. } 1836\] Splitting equally: \[\text{CGST} = \text{SGST} = \frac{1836}{2} = \text{Rs. } 918\] So Invoice III Total = Rs. 10200 + Rs. 1836 = Rs. 12036.
  4. Step 4: GST payable by the Wholesaler to the Government: The Wholesaler collected GST (from Invoice II) = Rs. 1710 and paid ITC (from Invoice I) = Rs. 1440. GST payable by Wholesaler: \[\text{GST} = 1710 - 1440 = \text{Rs. } 270\] \[\text{CGST payable} = 855 - 720 = \text{Rs. } 135\] \[\text{SGST payable} = 855 - 720 = \text{Rs. } 135\]
  5. Step 5: GST payable by the Distributor to the Government: The Distributor collected GST (from Invoice III) = Rs. 1836 and paid ITC (from Invoice II) = Rs. 1710. GST payable by Distributor: \[\text{GST} = 1836 - 1710 = \text{Rs. } 126\] \[\text{CGST payable} = 918 - 855 = \text{Rs. } 63\] \[\text{SGST payable} = 918 - 855 = \text{Rs. } 63\]
  6. Step 6: GST payable by the Retailer to the Government: The Retailer paid ITC on purchase (Invoice III) = Rs. 1836. The Retailer will charge GST on the final sale to the consumer. However, in this chain problem, the Retailer's GST liability from the government's perspective (as an input buyer) is represented by the ITC they hold. In the context of this chain, the Retailer's net GST payable shown here is the GST collected at the point of sale to the consumer minus ITC. Since only up to Invoice III is given, the ITC held by the Retailer = Rs. 1836 (CGST Rs. 918 + SGST Rs. 918). The net payable at this stage = Rs. 0 (as no further sale price is given); the Retailer holds the full ITC credit of CGST Rs. 918 and SGST Rs. 918 against future sales.
  7. Step 7: Summary of Tax Invoices and GST Payable: Invoice I: Taxable Value = Rs. 8000, GST = Rs. 1440 (CGST Rs. 720 + SGST Rs. 720). Invoice II: Taxable Value = Rs. 9500, GST = Rs. 1710 (CGST Rs. 855 + SGST Rs. 855). Invoice III: Taxable Value = Rs. 10200, GST = Rs. 1836 (CGST Rs. 918 + SGST Rs. 918). GST payable to Government — Wholesaler: CGST = Rs. 135, SGST = Rs. 135 (Total Rs. 270). Distributor: CGST = Rs. 63, SGST = Rs. 63 (Total Rs. 126).

Answer: Invoice I: GST = Rs. 1440 (CGST Rs. 720 + SGST Rs. 720). Invoice II: GST = Rs. 1710 (CGST Rs. 855 + SGST Rs. 855). Invoice III: GST = Rs. 1836 (CGST Rs. 918 + SGST Rs. 918). GST payable to Government: Wholesaler — CGST Rs. 135, SGST Rs. 135 (Total Rs. 270); Distributor — CGST Rs. 63, SGST Rs. 63 (Total Rs. 126).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Financial Planning

Chapter 4 Examples Q1 Practice Set 4.1 Q1 Practice Set 4.2 Q1 Practice Set 4.3 Q1 Practice Set 4.4 Q1 Problem Set 4A Q1 (i) Problem Set 4B Q1 (i) 04/2019 2019 / Question 3 QA (i) N362 2020 / Question 1 QA (i) N384 2024 / Question 3 QA (i) N384 2026 / Question 3 QA (i) N819 2025 / Question 3 QA (i) N919 2026 / Question 1 QA (i) N919 2026 / Question 3 QA (i) Chapter 4 Examples Q2 Practice Set 4.1 Q2 Practice Set 4.2 Q2 Practice Set 4.3 Q2 Practice Set 4.4 Q2 Problem Set 4A Q1 (ii) Problem Set 4B Q1 (ii) N362 2020 / Question 3 QA (ii) N384 2026 / Question 2 QA (ii) N619 2024 / Question 3 QA (ii) N684 2025 / Question 2 QA (ii) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (i) Chapter 4 Examples Q3 Practice Set 4.1 Q3 Practice Set 4.2 Q3 Practice Set 4.3 Q3 Practice Set 4.4 Q3 Problem Set 4A Q1 (iii) Problem Set 4B Q1 (iii) 04/2019 2019 / Question 4 Q3 N384 2024 / Question 2 QA (iii) N384 2026 / Question 1 QA (iii) N819 2025 / Question 2 QA (iii) N913 2023 / Question 2 QA (iii) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (ii) Practice Set 4.1 Q4 Chapter 4 Examples Q4 (i) Practice Set 4.2 Q4 Practice Set 4.3 Q4 Practice Set 4.4 Q4 Problem Set 4A Q1 (iv) Problem Set 4B Q1 (iv) 04/2019 2019 / Question 2 QA (iii) N619 2024 / Question 1 QA (iv) N684 2025 / Question 3 QB (ii) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (iii) Practice Set 4.1 Q5 Chapter 4 Examples Q4 (ii) Practice Set 4.2 Q5 Practice Set 4.3 Q5 Practice Set 4.4 Q5 Problem Set 4A Q1 (v) Problem Set 4B Q1 (v) N619 2024 / Question 3 QB(iii)i N919 2026 / Question 1 QB (i) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (iv)