SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Practice Set 4.3 Q6

If the face value of both the shares is same, then which investment out of the following is more profitable\(?\)
Company A : dividend \(16\%,\) MV \(=\) ₹\( 80,\) Company B : dividend \(20\%,\) MV \(=\) ₹\(120.\)

MAH STATE BOARD Mah SB Class 10 Maths · Financial Planning

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two shops selling magic money-boxes. Shop A charges less for its box but gives you a nice gift every year. Shop B charges more but gives a bigger gift. The real question is: which gift is bigger compared to what you paid? Company A's share costs only ₹80 but pays ₹16 back each year. Company B's share costs ₹120 but pays ₹20 back. Out of every ₹100 spent, Company A gives back more money. So Company A is the smarter buy.

Answer: Investment in Company A is more profitable, as it gives a rate of return of \( 20\% \) compared to about \( 16.67\% \) for Company B.

📖 Comparing Profitability of Two Shares

Detailed Explanation

When we buy a share, we pay the Market Value (MV), but the dividend is always calculated on the Face Value (FV). To decide which share is more profitable, we cannot just compare dividend percentages, because the money actually invested is the MV, not the FV. So we calculate the rate of return (also called yield), which tells us how much income we earn for every ₹100 we actually invest. The share with the higher rate of return is more profitable.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Rate of Return} = \dfrac{\text{Dividend per share}}{\text{Market Value}} \times 100\% \] where Dividend per share \( = \dfrac{\text{Dividend }\%}{100} \times \text{Face Value} \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Let the face value of each share be \( FV = ₹100 \) (since both companies have the same face value, we can assume any convenient value).
  2. Step 2: Calculate the dividend per share for Company A. Dividend rate is 16% on FV: \[ \text{Dividend}_A = \dfrac{16}{100} \times 100 = ₹16 \]
  3. Step 3: Calculate the rate of return for Company A. Here MV = ₹80: \[ \text{Return}_A = \dfrac{16}{80} \times 100 = 20\% \]
  4. Step 4: Calculate the dividend per share for Company B. Dividend rate is 20% on FV: \[ \text{Dividend}_B = \dfrac{20}{100} \times 100 = ₹20 \]
  5. Step 5: Calculate the rate of return for Company B. Here MV = ₹120: \[ \text{Return}_B = \dfrac{20}{120} \times 100 = 16.67\% \]
  6. Step 6: Compare the two rates of return. Company A gives \( 20\% \) while Company B gives about \( 16.67\% \). Since \( 20\% > 16.67\% \), Company A is more profitable.

Final Answer

Investment in Company A is more profitable, as it gives a rate of return of \( 20\% \) compared to about \( 16.67\% \) for Company B.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to directly compare the dividend percentages (16% vs 20%) and conclude that Company B is better. Remember, dividend % is on Face Value, but you actually pay the Market Value. Always compare the rate of return based on MV, not the dividend rate on FV.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Assume Face Value (FV) of each share is ₹100 for both companies. — Reason: The problem states both companies have the same face value, and ₹100 is a convenient standard value that makes percentage calculations straightforward.
  2. Step 2: Find the annual dividend paid per share by Company A. Company A declares a 16% dividend on Face Value, so: \[ \text{Dividend}_A = \frac{16}{100} \times 100 = \text{Rs. }16 \] — Reason: Dividend is always calculated on Face Value, NOT on the price you actually paid (Market Value).
  3. Step 3: Calculate the rate of return for Company A. The Market Value of Company A's share is ₹80. So: \[ \text{Return}_A = \frac{16}{80} \times 100 = 20\% \] — Reason: We divide the income earned (₹16) by the actual amount invested (₹80) to find how many rupees we earn per ₹100 invested.
  4. Step 4: Find the annual dividend paid per share by Company B. Company B declares a 20% dividend on Face Value, so: \[ \text{Dividend}_B = \frac{20}{100} \times 100 = \text{Rs. }20 \] — Reason: Again, the dividend percentage applies only to the Face Value of ₹100, regardless of the market price.
  5. Step 5: Calculate the rate of return for Company B. The Market Value of Company B's share is ₹120. So: \[ \text{Return}_B = \frac{20}{120} \times 100 \approx 16.67\% \] — Reason: Even though Company B pays a higher dividend in rupees (₹20 vs ₹16), you must spend ₹120 to earn that dividend, making the actual yield lower.
  6. Step 6: Compare the two rates of return. Company A gives \( 20\% \) and Company B gives approximately \( 16.67\% \). Since \( 20\% > 16.67\% \), Company A is the better investment. — Reason: The rate of return is the true measure of profitability because it accounts for how much money you actually had to spend; a higher rate means more income per rupee invested.

Final Answer

Investment in Company A is more profitable, as it gives a rate of return of \( 20\% \) compared to about \( 16.67\% \) for Company B.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students compare only the dividend percentages (16% vs 20%) and incorrectly conclude that Company B is more profitable, completely ignoring that the actual money invested differs — ₹80 for Company A versus ₹120 for Company B. Always compare the rate of return, not the dividend percentage.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: Face Value \( = ₹100 \) for both; Company A: Dividend \( = 16\% \), MV \( = ₹80 \); Company B: Dividend \( = 20\% \), MV \( = ₹120 \).
  2. Step 2: Return for Company A: \[ \text{Return}_A = \dfrac{\frac{16}{100} \times 100}{80} \times 100 = \dfrac{16}{80} \times 100 = 20\% \]
  3. Step 3: Return for Company B: \[ \text{Return}_B = \dfrac{\frac{20}{100} \times 100}{120} \times 100 = \dfrac{20}{120} \times 100 \approx 16.67\% \]
  4. Step 4: Comparison: \( 20\% > 16.67\% \), so Company A is more profitable.

Answer: Investment in Company A is more profitable, as it gives a rate of return of \( 20\% \) compared to about \( 16.67\% \) for Company B.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Two companies offer shares with the same face value of ₹100. Company P offers a dividend of 12% and its shares are available at a market value of ₹90. Company Q offers a dividend of 15% and its shares are available at a market value of ₹125. Which company's shares give a better return on investment?

Solution: The face value of both shares is ₹100. \nFor Company P:\nDividend earned per share = 12% of ₹100 \[= \frac{12}{100} \times 100 = ₹12\]\nReturn on investment for Company P: \[= \frac{12}{90} \times 100\] \[= \frac{1200}{90} \approx 13.33\%\] \nFor Company Q:\nDividend earned per share = 15% of ₹100 \[= \frac{15}{100} \times 100 = ₹15\]\nReturn on investment for Company Q: \[= \frac{15}{125} \times 100\] \[= \frac{1500}{125} = 12\%\] \nComparing the two: Return of Company P \(\approx 13.33\%\) and Return of Company Q \(= 12\%\). \nSince \(13.33\% > 12\%\), Company P's shares are more profitable.

Answer: Company P's investment is more profitable with a return of approximately 13.33% compared to Company Q's 12%.

Example 2

Question: Ravi is choosing between shares of two companies, both with a face value of ₹50. Company X declares a dividend of 18% and its market value is ₹72. Company Y declares a dividend of 24% and its market value is ₹108. Which is a better investment?

Solution: The face value of both shares is ₹50. \nFor Company X:\nDividend earned per share = 18% of ₹50 \[= \frac{18}{100} \times 50 = ₹9\]\nReturn on investment for Company X: \[= \frac{9}{72} \times 100\] \[= \frac{900}{72} = 12.5\%\] \nFor Company Y:\nDividend earned per share = 24% of ₹50 \[= \frac{24}{100} \times 50 = ₹12\]\nReturn on investment for Company Y: \[= \frac{12}{108} \times 100\] \[= \frac{1200}{108} \approx 11.11\%\] \nComparing the two: Return of Company X \(= 12.5\%\) and Return of Company Y \(\approx 11.11\%\). \nSince \(12.5\% > 11.11\%\), Company X's shares are the better investment.

Answer: Company X's investment is more profitable with a return of 12.5% compared to Company Y's approximately 11.11%.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The face value of shares of two companies is the same. Determine which investment is more profitable: Company P offers a dividend of \( 15\% \) and its shares are available at a market value of ₹ 125, while Company Q offers a dividend of \( 20\% \) and its shares are available at a market value of ₹ 140.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the given information: Both companies have the same face value. Let the face value of each share be ₹ 100 (a standard assumption when face value is not specified). Company P: Dividend = \( 15\% \), Market Value = ₹ 125. Company Q: Dividend = \( 20\% \), Market Value = ₹ 140.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the dividend per share for each company: Dividend per share for Company P: \[ \text{Dividend}_P = \frac{15}{100} \times 100 = ₹ \ 15 \] Dividend per share for Company Q: \[ \text{Dividend}_Q = \frac{20}{100} \times 100 = ₹ \ 20 \]
  3. Step 3: Calculate the rate of return for Company P: The rate of return is calculated on the market value (the actual investment made). For Company P: \[ \text{Rate of Return}_P = \frac{15}{125} \times 100 = 12\% \]
  4. Step 4: Calculate the rate of return for Company Q: For Company Q: \[ \text{Rate of Return}_Q = \frac{20}{140} \times 100 = \frac{2000}{140} \approx 14.29\% \]
  5. Step 5: Compare and conclude: Comparing the two rates of return: Company P gives \( 12\% \) and Company Q gives approximately \( 14.29\% \). Since \( 14.29\% > 12\% \), investment in Company Q is more profitable.

Answer: Investment in Company Q is more profitable, as it gives a rate of return of approximately \( 14.29\% \) compared to \( 12\% \) for Company P.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Financial Planning

Chapter 4 Examples Q1 Practice Set 4.1 Q1 Practice Set 4.2 Q1 Practice Set 4.3 Q1 Practice Set 4.4 Q1 Problem Set 4A Q1 (i) Problem Set 4B Q1 (i) 04/2019 2019 / Question 3 QA (i) N362 2020 / Question 1 QA (i) N384 2024 / Question 3 QA (i) N384 2026 / Question 3 QA (i) N819 2025 / Question 3 QA (i) N919 2026 / Question 1 QA (i) N919 2026 / Question 3 QA (i) Chapter 4 Examples Q2 Practice Set 4.1 Q2 Practice Set 4.2 Q2 Practice Set 4.3 Q2 Practice Set 4.4 Q2 Problem Set 4A Q1 (ii) Problem Set 4B Q1 (ii) N362 2020 / Question 3 QA (ii) N384 2026 / Question 2 QA (ii) N619 2024 / Question 3 QA (ii) N684 2025 / Question 2 QA (ii) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (i) Chapter 4 Examples Q3 Practice Set 4.1 Q3 Practice Set 4.2 Q3 Practice Set 4.3 Q3 Practice Set 4.4 Q3 Problem Set 4A Q1 (iii) Problem Set 4B Q1 (iii) 04/2019 2019 / Question 4 Q3 N384 2024 / Question 2 QA (iii) N384 2026 / Question 1 QA (iii) N819 2025 / Question 2 QA (iii) N913 2023 / Question 2 QA (iii) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (ii) Practice Set 4.1 Q4 Chapter 4 Examples Q4 (i) Practice Set 4.2 Q4 Practice Set 4.3 Q4 Practice Set 4.4 Q4 Problem Set 4A Q1 (iv) Problem Set 4B Q1 (iv) 04/2019 2019 / Question 2 QA (iii) N619 2024 / Question 1 QA (iv) N684 2025 / Question 3 QB (ii) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (iii) Practice Set 4.1 Q5 Chapter 4 Examples Q4 (ii) Practice Set 4.2 Q5 Practice Set 4.3 Q5 Practice Set 4.4 Q5 Problem Set 4A Q1 (v) Problem Set 4B Q1 (v) N619 2024 / Question 3 QB(iii)i N919 2026 / Question 1 QB (i) N919 2026 / Question 4 Q2 (iv)