Detailed Explanation
When we buy a share, we pay the Market Value (MV), but the dividend is always calculated on the Face Value (FV). To decide which share is more profitable, we cannot just compare dividend percentages, because the money actually invested is the MV, not the FV. So we calculate the rate of return (also called yield), which tells us how much income we earn for every ₹100 we actually invest. The share with the higher rate of return is more profitable.
Formula Used
\[ \text{Rate of Return} = \dfrac{\text{Dividend per share}}{\text{Market Value}} \times 100\% \] where Dividend per share \( = \dfrac{\text{Dividend }\%}{100} \times \text{Face Value} \).
Solution
- Step 1: Let the face value of each share be \( FV = ₹100 \) (since both companies have the same face value, we can assume any convenient value).
- Step 2: Calculate the dividend per share for Company A. Dividend rate is 16% on FV: \[ \text{Dividend}_A = \dfrac{16}{100} \times 100 = ₹16 \]
- Step 3: Calculate the rate of return for Company A. Here MV = ₹80: \[ \text{Return}_A = \dfrac{16}{80} \times 100 = 20\% \]
- Step 4: Calculate the dividend per share for Company B. Dividend rate is 20% on FV: \[ \text{Dividend}_B = \dfrac{20}{100} \times 100 = ₹20 \]
- Step 5: Calculate the rate of return for Company B. Here MV = ₹120: \[ \text{Return}_B = \dfrac{20}{120} \times 100 = 16.67\% \]
- Step 6: Compare the two rates of return. Company A gives \( 20\% \) while Company B gives about \( 16.67\% \). Since \( 20\% > 16.67\% \), Company A is more profitable.
Final Answer
Investment in Company A is more profitable, as it gives a rate of return of \( 20\% \) compared to about \( 16.67\% \) for Company B.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is to directly compare the dividend percentages (16% vs 20%) and conclude that Company B is better. Remember, dividend % is on Face Value, but you actually pay the Market Value. Always compare the rate of return based on MV, not the dividend rate on FV.