If the sum of first \(p\) terms of an \(A.P.\) is equal to the sum of first \(q\) terms then show that the sum of its first \((p+q)\) terms is zero. \((p\ne q)\)
MAH STATE BOARD Mah SB Class 10 Maths · Arithmetic Progressions
MAH STATE BOARD Mah SB Class 10 Maths · Arithmetic Progressions
Imagine two friends collecting stickers. One friend collects for \( p \) days, the other for \( q \) days. Both end up with the exact same total. That is a very special situation! Because they started the same way but collected for different amounts of time, the numbers must balance out perfectly. When you add up all the stickers collected over \( p + q \) days together, the positives and negatives cancel out completely. The grand total comes out to zero, just like a perfectly balanced seesaw.
Answer: The sum of the first \( (p+q) \) terms of the A.P. is \( 0 \).
In an Arithmetic Progression (A.P.) with first term \( a \) and common difference \( d \), the sum of the first \( n \) terms is given by a standard formula. Here we are told that the sum of the first \( p \) terms equals the sum of the first \( q \) terms (with \( p \ne q \)). We use the sum formula, form an equation from the given condition, simplify it to get a useful relation between \( a \) and \( d \), and then use that relation to compute the sum of the first \( (p+q) \) terms.
\[ S_n = \frac{n}{2}\left[2a + (n-1)d\right] \]
The sum of the first \( (p+q) \) terms of the A.P. is \( 0 \).
A common mistake is to cancel \( (p-q) \) without noting the condition \( p \ne q \). Cancellation is only valid because \( p \ne q \) ensures \( p - q \ne 0 \). Students should always state this reason clearly in their proof.
The sum of the first \( (p+q) \) terms of the A.P. is \( 0 \).
One common mistake: Students forget that dividing by \( (p - q) \) in Step 5 is only valid because \( p \ne q \) is explicitly given — always check and state this condition before dividing, otherwise the step is mathematically unjustified.
Answer: The sum of the first \( (p+q) \) terms of the A.P. is \( 0 \).
Question: In an A.P., the sum of the first \( m \) terms equals the sum of the first \( n \) terms, where \( m \ne n \). Prove that the sum of its first \( (m + n) \) terms is zero.
Solution: Let the first term of the A.P. be \( a \) and common difference be \( d \). \nWe are given that \( S_m = S_n \). \nUsing the formula for sum of an A.P.: \[S_m = \frac{m}{2}(2a + (m-1)d)\] \[S_n = \frac{n}{2}(2a + (n-1)d)\] \nSetting \( S_m = S_n \): \[\frac{m}{2}(2a + (m-1)d) = \frac{n}{2}(2a + (n-1)d)\] \nMultiplying both sides by 2: \[m(2a + (m-1)d) = n(2a + (n-1)d)\] \nExpanding both sides: \[2am + m(m-1)d = 2an + n(n-1)d\] \nRearranging: \[2am - 2an + m(m-1)d - n(n-1)d = 0\] \nFactoring: \[2a(m - n) + d[m^2 - m - n^2 + n] = 0\] \nGrouping the bracket: \[2a(m - n) + d[(m^2 - n^2) - (m - n)] = 0\] \nFactoring \( (m - n) \) from each term (recall \( m^2 - n^2 = (m-n)(m+n) \)): \[2a(m - n) + d(m - n)(m + n - 1) = 0\] \nSince \( m \ne n \), we can divide both sides by \( (m - n) \): \[2a + (m + n - 1)d = 0\] \nNow, the sum of the first \( (m + n) \) terms is: \[S_{m+n} = \frac{(m+n)}{2}(2a + (m+n-1)d)\] \nSubstituting \( 2a + (m+n-1)d = 0 \): \[S_{m+n} = \frac{(m+n)}{2} \times 0 = 0\] \nHence, the sum of the first \( (m + n) \) terms is zero.
Answer: \( S_{m+n} = 0 \)
Question: The sum of the first \( r \) terms of an A.P. is equal to the sum of its first \( s \) terms \( (r \ne s) \). Show that the sum of the first \( (r + s) \) terms of the A.P. is zero. Also verify your result using a specific numerical example with \( a = 5 \), \( d = -2 \), \( r = 3 \), \( s = 7 \).
Solution: Part 1 — General Proof: \nLet the A.P. have first term \( a \) and common difference \( d \). \nGiven: \( S_r = S_s \) \[\frac{r}{2}(2a + (r-1)d) = \frac{s}{2}(2a + (s-1)d)\] \nMultiplying throughout by 2: \[r(2a + (r-1)d) = s(2a + (s-1)d)\] \nExpanding: \[2ar + r(r-1)d = 2as + s(s-1)d\] \nRearranging: \[2a(r - s) + d[r(r-1) - s(s-1)] = 0\] \nExpanding the bracket: \[2a(r - s) + d[r^2 - r - s^2 + s] = 0\] \nGrouping: \[2a(r - s) + d[(r^2 - s^2) - (r - s)] = 0\] \nFactoring \( (r - s) \) using \( r^2 - s^2 = (r - s)(r + s) \): \[(r - s)[2a + d(r + s - 1)] = 0\] \nSince \( r \ne s \), we get: \[2a + (r + s - 1)d = 0\] \nNow computing \( S_{r+s} \): \[S_{r+s} = \frac{(r+s)}{2}[2a + (r+s-1)d] = \frac{(r+s)}{2} \times 0 = 0\] \nHence \( S_{r+s} = 0 \). \nPart 2 — Numerical Verification: \nGiven \( a = 5 \), \( d = -2 \), \( r = 3 \), \( s = 7 \). \nCompute \( S_3 \): \[S_3 = \frac{3}{2}(2 \times 5 + (3-1)(-2)) = \frac{3}{2}(10 - 4) = \frac{3}{2} \times 6 = 9\] \nCompute \( S_7 \): \[S_7 = \frac{7}{2}(2 \times 5 + (7-1)(-2)) = \frac{7}{2}(10 - 12) = \frac{7}{2} \times (-2) = -7\] \nHere \( S_3 \ne S_7 \), so this specific pair doesn't satisfy \( S_r = S_s \). Let us instead verify by finding what \( s \) gives \( S_s = S_3 = 9 \) for this A.P. \nFrom the general result, if \( S_r = S_s \) then \( 2a + (r+s-1)d = 0 \). \nWith \( a = 5 \), \( d = -2 \), \( r = 3 \): \[2(5) + (3 + s - 1)(-2) = 0\] \[10 - 2(s + 2) = 0\] \[10 - 2s - 4 = 0\] \[6 = 2s\]\nSo \( s = 3 \), but \( s \ne r \). Let us try \( a = 3 \), \( d = -1 \), \( r = 4 \), \( s = 6 \). \nCompute \( S_4 \): \[S_4 = \frac{4}{2}(2 \times 3 + 3 \times (-1)) = 2(6 - 3) = 2 \times 3 = 6\] \nCompute \( S_6 \): \[S_6 = \frac{6}{2}(2 \times 3 + 5 \times (-1)) = 3(6 - 5) = 3 \times 1 = 3\] \nThese are not equal either, so let us directly verify by checking \( S_{r+s} = S_{10} \) using \( a = 3 \), \( d = -1 \), where \( 2a + (r+s-1)d = 6 + 9(-1) = 6 - 9 = -3 \ne 0 \). A clean example: take \( a = 6 \), \( d = -2 \), \( r = 2 \), \( s = 8 \). \nCheck \( 2a + (r+s-1)d = 12 + 9(-2) = 12 - 18 = -6 \ne 0 \). Try \( r = 2 \), \( s = 6 \): \( 2(6) + (8-1)(-2) = 12 - 14 = -2 \ne 0 \). Use \( a = 7 \), \( d = -2 \), set \( 2(7)+(r+s-1)(-2)=0 \Rightarrow 14 = 2(r+s-1) \Rightarrow r+s = 8 \). Choose \( r = 3 \), \( s = 5 \). \nVerification with \( a = 7 \), \( d = -2 \), \( r = 3 \), \( s = 5 \): \nCompute \( S_3 \): \[S_3 = \frac{3}{2}(14 + 2(-2)) = \frac{3}{2}(10) = 15\] \nCompute \( S_5 \): \[S_5 = \frac{5}{2}(14 + 4(-2)) = \frac{5}{2}(6) = 15\] \nIndeed \( S_3 = S_5 = 15 \). Now compute \( S_8 \) (since \( r + s = 8 \)): \[S_8 = \frac{8}{2}(14 + 7(-2)) = 4(14 - 14) = 4 \times 0 = 0\] \nThis confirms \( S_{r+s} = 0 \).
Answer: \( S_{r+s} = 0 \); verified numerically with \( a = 7 \), \( d = -2 \), \( r = 3 \), \( s = 5 \): \( S_3 = S_5 = 15 \) and \( S_8 = 0 \).
Question: In an A.P., the sum of the first \( m \) terms equals the sum of the first \( n \) terms, where \( m \ne n \). Show that the sum of its first \( (m + n) \) terms is zero.
Answer: The sum of the first \( (m + n) \) terms of the A.P. is \( 0 \), proved by showing that the condition \( S_m = S_n \) (with \( m \ne n \)) forces \( 2a + (m+n-1)d = 0 \), which is exactly the bracket inside the formula for \( S_{m+n} \).