SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Miscellaneous Exercise Chapter 10 Q4

If \(\overrightarrow{a}= \overrightarrow{b}+\overrightarrow{c},\) then is it true that \(|\overrightarrow{a}|=|\overrightarrow{b}|+|\overrightarrow{c}|?\) Justify your answer.

CBSE Class 12 Maths · Vector Algebra

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you walk two blocks to reach a park. One block goes east, the other goes north. Your total shortcut distance is less than two blocks added together! That shortcut is like the vector \( \vec{a} \). The two individual walks are like \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \). Usually the shortcut is shorter than both walks combined. Only when both walks go in exactly the same direction does the shortcut equal their sum.

Answer: No, it is not true in general. By the triangle inequality \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \le |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \). Equality holds only when \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \) are like (parallel) vectors pointing in the same direction.

📖 Is the Magnitude of a Sum Equal to the Sum of Magnitudes?

Detailed Explanation

When we add two vectors \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \), we place them head-to-tail, and the resultant \( \vec{a} = \vec{b} + \vec{c} \) is the vector joining the start of \( \vec{b} \) to the tip of \( \vec{c} \). This forms a triangle. A basic property of any triangle is that the length of one side can never exceed the sum of the lengths of the other two sides. This gives us the triangle inequality for vectors: \( |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \le |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \). So in general, \( |\vec{a}| \) is less than or equal to \( |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \), not necessarily equal to it. Equality holds only in the special case when \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \) point in the same direction (are parallel with the same sense).

Formula Used

\[ |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \le |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \quad (\text{triangle inequality}) \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the triangle law of addition. Since \( \vec{a} = \vec{b} + \vec{c} \), the three vectors form a triangle when placed head-to-tail. The magnitudes \( |\vec{a}| \), \( |\vec{b}| \), \( |\vec{c}| \) are the lengths of the sides of this triangle.
  2. Step 2: Apply the triangle inequality. For any triangle, one side is at most the sum of the other two. Therefore \[ |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \le |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}|. \] This shows the statement \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \) is not true in general.
  3. Step 3: Test with a counterexample. Let \( \vec{b} = \hat{i} \) and \( \vec{c} = \hat{j} \). Then \[ \vec{a} = \vec{b} + \vec{c} = \hat{i} + \hat{j}. \] Computing magnitudes: \[ |\vec{a}| = \sqrt{1^2 + 1^2} = \sqrt{2}, \] while \[ |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| = 1 + 1 = 2. \] Since \( \sqrt{2} \ne 2 \), the equality fails here.
  4. Step 4: Identify when equality holds. Equality \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \) occurs only when \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \) are parallel and point in the same direction. For example, if \( \vec{b} = \hat{i} \) and \( \vec{c} = 2\hat{i} \), then \( |\vec{a}| = 3 \) and \( |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| = 1 + 2 = 3 \), which agree.

Final Answer

No, it is not true in general. By the triangle inequality \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \le |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \). Equality holds only when \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \) are like (parallel) vectors pointing in the same direction.

Common Mistake

Students often assume magnitudes add just like the vectors do, writing \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \) automatically. This ignores direction: magnitudes add only when the vectors are collinear and same-directed; otherwise the resultant's magnitude is strictly smaller.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Set up the problem using the triangle law of vector addition. Since \( \vec{a} = \vec{b} + \vec{c} \), place \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \) head-to-tail; the resultant \( \vec{a} \) connects the tail of \( \vec{b} \) to the head of \( \vec{c} \), forming a triangle. — Reason: Visualising vector addition as a triangle lets us use a well-known geometric property about side lengths.
  2. Step 2: Identify the sides of the triangle. The three sides have lengths \( |\vec{a}| \), \( |\vec{b}| \), and \( |\vec{c}| \). — Reason: The magnitudes of the vectors correspond exactly to the side lengths of the triangle formed by head-to-tail placement.
  3. Step 3: Apply the triangle inequality. In any triangle, the length of one side cannot exceed the sum of the other two, so \[ |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \le |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}|. \] — Reason: This is a fundamental geometric fact — the shortest path between two points is a straight line, so the direct side is never longer than the two-step path.
  4. Step 4: Use a counterexample to confirm the inequality is strict in general. Let \( \vec{b} = \hat{i} \) and \( \vec{c} = \hat{j} \). Then \[ \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j}, \] so \( |\vec{a}| = \sqrt{1^2 + 1^2} = \sqrt{2} \), while \( |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| = 1 + 1 = 2 \). Since \( \sqrt{2} \ne 2 \), the statement \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \) is false here. — Reason: A single counterexample is enough to prove that a general claim is not always true.
  5. Step 5: Determine when equality does hold. The triangle inequality becomes an equality \[ |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| = |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \] only when the triangle degenerates — that is, when \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \) are parallel and point in the same direction (like vectors). In this special case, adding them produces no "shortcut," and the resultant magnitude equals the full sum. — Reason: Understanding the equality condition helps identify the only situation where the claim in the question would actually be valid.

Final Answer

No, it is not true in general. By the triangle inequality \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \le |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \). Equality holds only when \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \) are like (parallel) vectors pointing in the same direction.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students assume that because \( \vec{a} = \vec{b} + \vec{c} \) (vector addition), the magnitudes must also add up as \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \). This confuses vector addition with scalar addition — magnitude does not distribute over vector addition in general.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: \( \vec{a} = \vec{b} + \vec{c} \), so \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \).
  2. Step 2: By the triangle inequality: \[ |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \le |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \] so \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \) is NOT true in general.
  3. Step 3: Counterexample: \( \vec{b} = \hat{i} \), \( \vec{c} = \hat{j} \) gives \( |\vec{a}| = \sqrt{2} \), but \( |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| = 2 \), confirming \( |\vec{a}| < |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \).

Answer: No, it is not true in general. By the triangle inequality \( |\vec{a}| = |\vec{b} + \vec{c}| \le |\vec{b}| + |\vec{c}| \). Equality holds only when \( \vec{b} \) and \( \vec{c} \) are like (parallel) vectors pointing in the same direction.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: If \(\vec{p} = \vec{q} + \vec{r}\), is it necessarily true that \(|\vec{p}| = |\vec{q}| + |\vec{r}|\)? Justify your answer with a suitable example.

Solution: We claim the statement is NOT necessarily true. Consider two specific vectors: \(\vec{q} = 3\hat{i} + 4\hat{j}\) and \(\vec{r} = -3\hat{i} + 4\hat{j}\). Then \(\vec{p} = \vec{q} + \vec{r} = (3\hat{i} + 4\hat{j}) + (-3\hat{i} + 4\hat{j}) = 8\hat{j}\). Now compute the magnitudes: \[|\vec{p}| = |8\hat{j}| = 8\] \[|\vec{q}| = \sqrt{3^2 + 4^2} = \sqrt{9 + 16} = \sqrt{25} = 5\] \[|\vec{r}| = \sqrt{(-3)^2 + 4^2} = \sqrt{9 + 16} = \sqrt{25} = 5\] So \(|\vec{q}| + |\vec{r}| = 5 + 5 = 10\), but \(|\vec{p}| = 8\). Since \(8 \ne 10\), we see that \(|\vec{p}| \ne |\vec{q}| + |\vec{r}|\) in general. In general, by the triangle inequality for vectors: \[|\vec{p}| = |\vec{q} + \vec{r}| \le |\vec{q}| + |\vec{r}|\] Equality holds if and only if \(\vec{q}\) and \(\vec{r}\) are parallel and point in the same direction (i.e., one is a non-negative scalar multiple of the other). Therefore, the statement \(|\vec{p}| = |\vec{q}| + |\vec{r}|\) is NOT always true.

Answer: No, \(|\vec{p}| = |\vec{q}| + |\vec{r}|\) is not necessarily true. It holds only when \(\vec{q}\) and \(\vec{r}\) are parallel and co-directional.

Example 2

Question: Vectors \(\vec{u}\) and \(\vec{v}\) are such that \(\vec{w} = \vec{u} + \vec{v}\). A student claims that \(|\vec{w}| = |\vec{u}| + |\vec{v}|\) always. Is this claim correct? Give a counterexample using \(\vec{u} = 2\hat{i} - 2\hat{j}\) and \(\vec{v} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j}\) to justify your answer, and state when the equality does hold.

Solution: We check whether the student's claim holds for the given vectors. Given: \(\vec{u} = 2\hat{i} - 2\hat{j}\) and \(\vec{v} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j}\). Compute \(\vec{w}\): \[\vec{w} = \vec{u} + \vec{v} = (2\hat{i} - 2\hat{j}) + (2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j}) = 4\hat{i}\] Now find the individual magnitudes: \[|\vec{u}| = \sqrt{2^2 + (-2)^2} = \sqrt{4 + 4} = \sqrt{8} = 2\sqrt{2}\] \[|\vec{v}| = \sqrt{2^2 + 2^2} = \sqrt{4 + 4} = \sqrt{8} = 2\sqrt{2}\] \[|\vec{w}| = |4\hat{i}| = 4\] Left-hand side: \(|\vec{w}| = 4\). Right-hand side: \(|\vec{u}| + |\vec{v}| = 2\sqrt{2} + 2\sqrt{2} = 4\sqrt{2} \approx 5.66\). Since \(4 \ne 4\sqrt{2}\), we have \(|\vec{w}| \ne |\vec{u}| + |\vec{v}|\). This disproves the student's claim. The triangle inequality states: \[|\vec{u} + \vec{v}| \le |\vec{u}| + |\vec{v}|\] The equality \(|\vec{w}| = |\vec{u}| + |\vec{v}|\) holds if and only if \(\vec{u}\) and \(\vec{v}\) are parallel and point in the same direction, i.e., \(\vec{u} = \lambda \vec{v}\) for some scalar \(\lambda \ge 0\). Therefore, the student's claim is incorrect in general.

Answer: No, the claim is incorrect. For \(\vec{u} = 2\hat{i} - 2\hat{j}\) and \(\vec{v} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j}\), we get \(|\vec{w}| = 4\) but \(|\vec{u}| + |\vec{v}| = 4\sqrt{2}\). Equality holds only when \(\vec{u}\) and \(\vec{v}\) are parallel and co-directional.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: If \( \vec{p} = \vec{r} - \vec{q} \), is it necessarily true that \( |\vec{p}| = |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \)? Justify your answer with a suitable example.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Rewrite the given relation: We are given \( \vec{p} = \vec{r} - \vec{q} \). We need to check whether \( |\vec{p}| = |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \) is always true.
  2. Step 2: Use the Triangle Inequality: By the triangle inequality applied to vector subtraction, for any two vectors \( \vec{r} \) and \( \vec{q} \): \[ |\vec{r} - \vec{q}| \ge \bigl| |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \bigr| \] This means \( |\vec{p}| \ge \bigl| |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \bigr| \ge |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \) in general. So \( |\vec{p}| = |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \) need not hold.
  3. Step 3: Provide a counterexample: Let \( \vec{r} = 3\hat{i} + 4\hat{j} \) and \( \vec{q} = \hat{i} + 2\hat{j} \). Then \( \vec{p} = \vec{r} - \vec{q} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} \). Now compute the magnitudes: \[ |\vec{r}| = \sqrt{3^2 + 4^2} = \sqrt{25} = 5 \] \[ |\vec{q}| = \sqrt{1^2 + 2^2} = \sqrt{5} \] \[ |\vec{p}| = \sqrt{2^2 + 2^2} = \sqrt{8} = 2\sqrt{2} \] Now check: \[ |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| = 5 - \sqrt{5} \approx 5 - 2.236 = 2.764 \] But \( |\vec{p}| = 2\sqrt{2} \approx 2.828 \). Since \( 2\sqrt{2} \ne 5 - \sqrt{5} \), the equality does not hold.
  4. Step 4: State when equality holds: Equality \( |\vec{p}| = |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \) holds if and only if \( \vec{r} \) and \( \vec{q} \) are parallel (like vectors pointing in the same direction) and \( |\vec{r}| \ge |\vec{q}| \). In that special case \( \vec{r} - \vec{q} \) has magnitude exactly \( |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \). In all other cases, \( |\vec{p}| > |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \).

Answer: No, it is not necessarily true that \( |\vec{p}| = |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \). By the triangle inequality, \( |\vec{p}| = |\vec{r} - \vec{q}| \ge \bigl| |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| \bigr| \). The counterexample with \( \vec{r} = 3\hat{i} + 4\hat{j} \) and \( \vec{q} = \hat{i} + 2\hat{j} \) gives \( |\vec{p}| = 2\sqrt{2} \) while \( |\vec{r}| - |\vec{q}| = 5 - \sqrt{5} \), which are unequal. Equality holds only when \( \vec{r} \) and \( \vec{q} \) are parallel (same direction) and \( |\vec{r}| \ge |\vec{q}| \).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Vector Algebra

Chapter 10 Examples Q1 Chapter 10 Examples Q2(i) Chapter 10 Examples Q2(ii) Chapter 10 Examples Q2(iii) 65/2/1 2022 / Section A Q3 65/2/2 2023 / Section A Q4 Chapter 10 Examples Q2(iv) 65/2/2 2023 / Section A Q5 65/4/1 2022 / Section A Q4(a) Chapter 10 Examples Q2(v) 65/2/2 2023 / Section A Q6 65/4/1 2022 / Section A Q4(b) Chapter 10 Examples Q2(vi) 65/1/1 2024 / Section A Q7 Chapter 10 Examples Q3(i) 65/1/1 2023 / Section A Q8 65/2/1 2022 / Section B Q7 65/2/1 2024 / Section A Q8 65/3/1 2024 / Section A Q8 Chapter 10 Examples Q3(ii) 65/1/1 2023 / Section A Q9 Chapter 10 Examples Q3(iii) 65/1/1 2023 / Section A Q10 65/3/1 2023 / Section A Q10 Chapter 10 Examples Q4 65/3/1 2023 / Section A Q11 Chapter 10 Examples Q5 65(B) 2026 / Section A Q12 65/3/1 2023 / Section A Q12 65/4/1 2022 / Section B Q9 65/4/1 2023 / Section A Q12 Chapter 10 Examples Q6 65(B) 2026 / Section A Q13 65/1/1 2026 / Section A Q13 65/3/1 2023 / Section A Q13 65/4/1 2023 / Section A Q13 Chapter 10 Examples Q7 65/1/1 2026 / Section A Q14 65/3/1 2026 / Section A Q14 65/4/2 2024 / Section A Q14 Chapter 10 Examples Q8 65/1/1 2024 / Section A Q15 65/1/1 2026 / Section A Q15 65/2/1 2024 / Section A Q15 65/3/1 2024 / Section A Q15 65/3/1 2026 / Section A Q15 65/4/2 2024 / Section A Q15 Chapter 10 Examples Q9 65/4/1 2026 / Section A Q16 65/4/2 2024 / Section A Q16 65/5/1 2026 / Section A Q16 Chapter 10 Examples Q10 65/2/3 2026 / Section A Q17 65/4/1 2026 / Section A Q17 65/4/2 2024 / Section A Q17 65/5/1 2026 / Section A Q17 Chapter 10 Examples Q11(i) 65/2/3 2026 / Section A Q18 Chapter 10 Examples Q11(ii) 65/2/3 2026 / Section A Q19