SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 10.4 Q8

If either \(\overrightarrow{a}=\overrightarrow{0}\) or \(\overrightarrow{b}=\overrightarrow{0},\) then \(\overrightarrow{a}\times\overrightarrow{b}=\overrightarrow{0}.\) Is the converse true? Justify your answer with an example.

CBSE Class 12 Maths · Vector Algebra

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two arrows lying flat on a table, both pointing the same direction. They never cross each other, so there is no "twist" between them. The cross product measures that twist. Two arrows can have zero twist without either arrow disappearing — they just have to point the same way. So knowing the twist is zero does not tell you the arrows are gone. It only tells you they are lined up perfectly, like two cars driving side by side on the same road.

Answer: No, the converse is not true. If \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), it does not force either vector to be zero, because the cross product also vanishes when the vectors are parallel (\( \sin\theta = 0 \)). For example, \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} + \hat{k} \) and \( \vec{b} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} + 2\hat{k} \) are both non-zero but give \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \).

📖 Converse of the Zero Cross Product Rule

Detailed Explanation

The cross product of two vectors is given by \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = |\vec{a}||\vec{b}| \sin\theta \, \hat{n} \), where \( \theta \) is the angle between the vectors and \( \hat{n} \) is a unit vector perpendicular to both. If either vector is the zero vector, its magnitude is zero, so the cross product is automatically the zero vector. This gives the original statement. The converse asks the opposite: if \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), must one of the vectors be zero? This is NOT always true. The cross product can also become zero when \( \sin\theta = 0 \), that is, when the two vectors are parallel or collinear (\( \theta = 0^\circ \) or \( \theta = 180^\circ \)). So two non-zero parallel vectors give a zero cross product, which breaks the converse.

Formula Used

\[ \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = |\vec{a}||\vec{b}| \sin\theta \, \hat{n} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: State the converse to be tested. The converse of the given statement is: If \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), then either \( \vec{a} = \vec{0} \) or \( \vec{b} = \vec{0} \). We must check whether this is always true.
  2. Step 2: Recall when a cross product becomes zero. Since \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = |\vec{a}||\vec{b}| \sin\theta \, \hat{n} \), the cross product is zero whenever \( |\vec{a}| = 0 \), or \( |\vec{b}| = 0 \), or \( \sin\theta = 0 \). The last case, \( \sin\theta = 0 \), happens when the vectors are parallel, without needing either vector to be zero.
  3. Step 3: Construct a counter-example using parallel vectors. Take \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} + \hat{k} \) and \( \vec{b} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} + 2\hat{k} \). Here \( \vec{b} = 2\vec{a} \), so the vectors are parallel but neither is the zero vector.
  4. Step 4: Compute the cross product. \[ \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \begin{vmatrix} \hat{i} & \hat{j} & \hat{k} \\ 1 & 1 & 1 \\ 2 & 2 & 2 \end{vmatrix} \] Expanding, \[ \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \hat{i}(1\cdot 2 - 1\cdot 2) - \hat{j}(1\cdot 2 - 1\cdot 2) + \hat{k}(1\cdot 2 - 1\cdot 2) \] which gives \[ \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = 0\hat{i} - 0\hat{j} + 0\hat{k} = \vec{0}. \]
  5. Step 5: Draw the conclusion. Here \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), yet \( \vec{a} \ne \vec{0} \) and \( \vec{b} \ne \vec{0} \). This single example disproves the converse.

Final Answer

No, the converse is not true. If \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), it does not force either vector to be zero, because the cross product also vanishes when the vectors are parallel (\( \sin\theta = 0 \)). For example, \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} + \hat{k} \) and \( \vec{b} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} + 2\hat{k} \) are both non-zero but give \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is assuming that a zero cross product can only mean one of the vectors is zero, forgetting the case \( \sin\theta = 0 \) where non-zero parallel (collinear) vectors also produce the zero vector.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the original statement and write its converse. The original statement is: if \( \vec{a} = \vec{0} \) or \( \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), then \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \). Its converse reverses the direction of implication: if \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), then \( \vec{a} = \vec{0} \) or \( \vec{b} = \vec{0} \). — Reason: We need to clearly state what claim we are testing before attempting to verify or disprove it.
  2. Step 2: Apply the cross product formula to see all conditions that make it zero. From \[ \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = |\vec{a}||\vec{b}| \sin\theta \, \hat{n} \] the product equals \( \vec{0} \) whenever \( |\vec{a}| = 0 \), or \( |\vec{b}| = 0 \), or \( \sin\theta = 0 \). — Reason: By identifying every factor that can be zero, we find all possible causes of a zero cross product, not just the one mentioned in the converse.
  3. Step 3: Analyse the third condition \( \sin\theta = 0 \). This occurs when \( \theta = 0^{\circ} \) or \( \theta = 180^{\circ} \), meaning the vectors point in the same or opposite directions (they are parallel or anti-parallel). Neither vector needs to be zero for this to happen. — Reason: This condition is independent of whether the vectors are zero, which immediately suggests the converse can fail.
  4. Step 4: Construct a concrete counter-example. Let \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} + \hat{k} \) and \( \vec{b} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} + 2\hat{k} \). Both vectors are clearly non-zero, and \( \vec{b} = 2\vec{a} \), so they are parallel with \( \theta = 0^{\circ} \). — Reason: A single counter-example is sufficient to disprove a general statement; choosing \( \vec{b} \) as a scalar multiple of \( \vec{a} \) guarantees parallelism.
  5. Step 5: Verify the cross product for the counter-example. Compute \[ \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \begin{vmatrix} \hat{i} & \hat{j} & \hat{k} \\ 1 & 1 & 1 \\ 2 & 2 & 2 \end{vmatrix} \] Expanding: \( \hat{i}(1 \cdot 2 - 1 \cdot 2) - \hat{j}(1 \cdot 2 - 1 \cdot 2) + \hat{k}(1 \cdot 2 - 1 \cdot 2) \) which gives \( \hat{i}(0) - \hat{j}(0) + \hat{k}(0) = \vec{0} \). — Reason: Explicit computation confirms that the cross product is indeed zero even though neither \( \vec{a} \) nor \( \vec{b} \) is the zero vector.
  6. Step 6: State the conclusion. Since we found two non-zero vectors whose cross product is \( \vec{0} \), the converse is false. The condition \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \) does not guarantee that either vector is zero; it could simply mean the vectors are parallel. — Reason: The counter-example directly contradicts the converse, so the converse cannot hold in general.

Final Answer

No, the converse is not true. If \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), it does not force either vector to be zero, because the cross product also vanishes when the vectors are parallel (\( \sin\theta = 0 \)). For example, \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} + \hat{k} \) and \( \vec{b} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} + 2\hat{k} \) are both non-zero but give \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students assume that a zero cross product always means at least one vector must be the zero vector, forgetting that \( \sin\theta = 0 \) when the vectors are parallel — a completely separate reason for the cross product to vanish.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Converse to test: If \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), then \( \vec{a} = \vec{0} \) or \( \vec{b} = \vec{0} \).
  2. Step 2: \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \) when \( |\vec{a}| = 0 \), or \( |\vec{b}| = 0 \), or \( \sin\theta = 0 \) (i.e., vectors are parallel).
  3. Step 3: Counter-example: \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} + \hat{k} \), \( \vec{b} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} + 2\hat{k} \) are parallel and non-zero, yet \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \).

Answer: No, the converse is not true. If \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), it does not force either vector to be zero, because the cross product also vanishes when the vectors are parallel (\( \sin\theta = 0 \)). For example, \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} + \hat{k} \) and \( \vec{b} = 2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} + 2\hat{k} \) are both non-zero but give \( \vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0} \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: If \(\vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0}\), does it necessarily mean that \(\vec{a} = \vec{0}\) or \(\vec{b} = \vec{0}\)? Justify your answer with a suitable example.

Solution: We know the cross product formula: \[\vec{a} \times \vec{b} = |\vec{a}||\vec{b}|\sin\theta\, \hat{n}\] where \(\theta\) is the angle between the vectors. So \(\vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0}\) whenever \(\sin\theta = 0\), i.e., \(\theta = 0^{\circ}\) or \(\theta = 180^{\circ}\). This happens not only when one vector is zero, but also when both vectors are non-zero and parallel. Therefore, the converse is NOT true. Counter-example: Let \(\vec{a} = 2\hat{i} + 4\hat{j} - 2\hat{k}\) and \(\vec{b} = \hat{i} + 2\hat{j} - \hat{k}\). Clearly neither \(\vec{a} = \vec{0}\) nor \(\vec{b} = \vec{0}\). Note that \(\vec{a} = 2\vec{b}\), so they are parallel and the angle between them is \(0^{\circ}\). Now compute \(\vec{a} \times \vec{b}\): \[\vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \begin{vmatrix} \hat{i} & \hat{j} & \hat{k} \\ 2 & 4 & -2 \\ 1 & 2 & -1 \end{vmatrix}\] Expanding along the first row: \[\vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \hat{i}\bigl(4 \cdot (-1) - (-2) \cdot 2\bigr) - \hat{j}\bigl(2 \cdot (-1) - (-2) \cdot 1\bigr) + \hat{k}\bigl(2 \cdot 2 - 4 \cdot 1\bigr)\] Simplifying each component: \[\vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \hat{i}(-4 + 4) - \hat{j}(-2 + 2) + \hat{k}(4 - 4)\] Therefore: \[\vec{a} \times \vec{b} = 0\hat{i} - 0\hat{j} + 0\hat{k} = \vec{0}\] Thus \(\vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0}\) even though neither \(\vec{a}\) nor \(\vec{b}\) is the zero vector. Hence the converse is NOT true.

Answer: No, the converse is not true. For example, \(\vec{a} = 2\hat{i} + 4\hat{j} - 2\hat{k}\) and \(\vec{b} = \hat{i} + 2\hat{j} - \hat{k}\) are both non-zero, yet \(\vec{a} \times \vec{b} = \vec{0}\) because they are parallel.

Example 2

Question: Two vectors \(\vec{p} = 3\hat{i} - 6\hat{j} + 9\hat{k}\) and \(\vec{q} = -\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} - 3\hat{k}\) are given. Compute \(\vec{p} \times \vec{q}\) and use the result to comment on the converse of the statement: 'If \(\vec{p} = \vec{0}\) or \(\vec{q} = \vec{0}\), then \(\vec{p} \times \vec{q} = \vec{0}\).'

Solution: First, observe that \(\vec{p} = -3\vec{q}\), since: \[-3\vec{q} = -3(-\hat{i} + 2\hat{j} - 3\hat{k}) = 3\hat{i} - 6\hat{j} + 9\hat{k} = \vec{p}\] So \(\vec{p}\) and \(\vec{q}\) are anti-parallel (angle between them is \(180^{\circ}\)), and neither is the zero vector. Now compute \(\vec{p} \times \vec{q}\) using the determinant method: \[\vec{p} \times \vec{q} = \begin{vmatrix} \hat{i} & \hat{j} & \hat{k} \\ 3 & -6 & 9 \\ -1 & 2 & -3 \end{vmatrix}\] Expanding: \[\vec{p} \times \vec{q} = \hat{i}\bigl((-6)(-3) - (9)(2)\bigr) - \hat{j}\bigl((3)(-3) - (9)(-1)\bigr) + \hat{k}\bigl((3)(2) - (-6)(-1)\bigr)\] Computing each bracket: \[\vec{p} \times \vec{q} = \hat{i}(18 - 18) - \hat{j}(-9 + 9) + \hat{k}(6 - 6)\] Therefore: \[\vec{p} \times \vec{q} = 0\hat{i} - 0\hat{j} + 0\hat{k} = \vec{0}\] Since \(|\vec{p}| = \sqrt{9 + 36 + 81} = \sqrt{126} \ne 0\) and \(|\vec{q}| = \sqrt{1 + 4 + 9} = \sqrt{14} \ne 0\), neither vector is zero, yet their cross product is zero. This is because \(\sin 180^{\circ} = 0\), so \(\vec{p} \times \vec{q} = |\vec{p}||\vec{q}|\sin 180^{\circ}\,\hat{n} = \vec{0}\). Conclusion: The converse of the given statement is NOT true in general. \(\vec{p} \times \vec{q} = \vec{0}\) does not imply that \(\vec{p} = \vec{0}\) or \(\vec{q} = \vec{0}\); it can also happen when the vectors are parallel or anti-parallel.

Answer: \(\vec{p} \times \vec{q} = \vec{0}\), even though neither \(\vec{p}\) nor \(\vec{q}\) is the zero vector. The converse is NOT true; parallel (or anti-parallel) non-zero vectors also give a zero cross product.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: If either \( \vec{a} = \vec{0} \) or \( \vec{b} = \vec{0} \), then \( \vec{a} \cdot \vec{b} = 0 \). Is the converse true? That is, if \( \vec{a} \cdot \vec{b} = 0 \), does it necessarily follow that \( \vec{a} = \vec{0} \) or \( \vec{b} = \vec{0} \)? Justify your answer with an example.

Solution

  1. Step 1: State the formula for the dot product: Recall that for any two vectors \( \vec{a} \) and \( \vec{b} \), the dot product is given by \[ \vec{a} \cdot \vec{b} = |\vec{a}||\vec{b}|\cos\theta \] where \( \theta \) is the angle between the two vectors.
  2. Step 2: Analyse when the dot product equals zero: The product \( |\vec{a}||\vec{b}|\cos\theta = 0 \) holds if any one of the three factors is zero. So the dot product is zero when \( |\vec{a}| = 0 \) (i.e. \( \vec{a} = \vec{0} \)), OR when \( |\vec{b}| = 0 \) (i.e. \( \vec{b} = \vec{0} \)), OR when \( \cos\theta = 0 \), meaning \( \theta = 90^\circ \), i.e. the vectors are perpendicular.
  3. Step 3: Conclude about the converse: The converse states: if \( \vec{a} \cdot \vec{b} = 0 \), then \( \vec{a} = \vec{0} \) or \( \vec{b} = \vec{0} \). This is NOT necessarily true, because the dot product can also vanish when the two non-zero vectors are perpendicular to each other (i.e. \( \cos 90^\circ = 0 \)).
  4. Step 4: Provide a counterexample: Let \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} \) and \( \vec{b} = \hat{i} - \hat{j} \). Both vectors are clearly non-zero. Computing their dot product: \[ \vec{a} \cdot \vec{b} = (\hat{i} + \hat{j}) \cdot (\hat{i} - \hat{j}) = (1)(1) + (1)(-1) = 1 - 1 = 0 \] So \( \vec{a} \cdot \vec{b} = 0 \) even though neither \( \vec{a} \) nor \( \vec{b} \) is the zero vector.
  5. Step 5: Final conclusion: The converse is NOT true. The dot product \( \vec{a} \cdot \vec{b} = 0 \) does not force either vector to be zero, because it also equals zero whenever the two vectors are perpendicular. The counterexample \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} \) and \( \vec{b} = \hat{i} - \hat{j} \) demonstrates this clearly.

Answer: No, the converse is not true. If \( \vec{a} \cdot \vec{b} = 0 \), it does not force either vector to be zero, because the dot product also vanishes when the vectors are perpendicular (\( \cos\theta = 0 \)). For example, \( \vec{a} = \hat{i} + \hat{j} \) and \( \vec{b} = \hat{i} - \hat{j} \) are both non-zero yet give \( \vec{a} \cdot \vec{b} = 0 \).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Vector Algebra

Chapter 10 Examples Q1 Chapter 10 Examples Q2(i) Chapter 10 Examples Q2(ii) Chapter 10 Examples Q2(iii) 65/2/1 2022 / Section A Q3 65/2/2 2023 / Section A Q4 Chapter 10 Examples Q2(iv) 65/2/2 2023 / Section A Q5 65/4/1 2022 / Section A Q4(a) Chapter 10 Examples Q2(v) 65/2/2 2023 / Section A Q6 65/4/1 2022 / Section A Q4(b) Chapter 10 Examples Q2(vi) 65/1/1 2024 / Section A Q7 Chapter 10 Examples Q3(i) 65/1/1 2023 / Section A Q8 65/2/1 2022 / Section B Q7 65/2/1 2024 / Section A Q8 65/3/1 2024 / Section A Q8 Chapter 10 Examples Q3(ii) 65/1/1 2023 / Section A Q9 Chapter 10 Examples Q3(iii) 65/1/1 2023 / Section A Q10 65/3/1 2023 / Section A Q10 Chapter 10 Examples Q4 65/3/1 2023 / Section A Q11 Chapter 10 Examples Q5 65(B) 2026 / Section A Q12 65/3/1 2023 / Section A Q12 65/4/1 2022 / Section B Q9 65/4/1 2023 / Section A Q12 Chapter 10 Examples Q6 65(B) 2026 / Section A Q13 65/1/1 2026 / Section A Q13 65/3/1 2023 / Section A Q13 65/4/1 2023 / Section A Q13 Chapter 10 Examples Q7 65/1/1 2026 / Section A Q14 65/3/1 2026 / Section A Q14 65/4/2 2024 / Section A Q14 Chapter 10 Examples Q8 65/1/1 2024 / Section A Q15 65/1/1 2026 / Section A Q15 65/2/1 2024 / Section A Q15 65/3/1 2024 / Section A Q15 65/3/1 2026 / Section A Q15 65/4/2 2024 / Section A Q15 Chapter 10 Examples Q9 65/4/1 2026 / Section A Q16 65/4/2 2024 / Section A Q16 65/5/1 2026 / Section A Q16 Chapter 10 Examples Q10 65/2/3 2026 / Section A Q17 65/4/1 2026 / Section A Q17 65/4/2 2024 / Section A Q17 65/5/1 2026 / Section A Q17 Chapter 10 Examples Q11(i) 65/2/3 2026 / Section A Q18 Chapter 10 Examples Q11(ii) 65/2/3 2026 / Section A Q19