Detailed Explanation
Two vectors \( \vec{a} \) and \( \vec{b} \) are said to be collinear if they are parallel to the same line, irrespective of their magnitudes and directions. The key defining property is that one vector can be written as a scalar multiple of the other, that is \( \vec{b} = \lambda \vec{a} \) for some scalar \( \lambda \). This scalar \( \lambda \) can be positive (same direction), negative (opposite direction), and can have any magnitude (so the lengths may differ). A direct consequence is that their corresponding components are always proportional. Using these facts, we test each statement.
Formula Used
If \( \vec{a} \) and \( \vec{b} \) are collinear, then \( \vec{b} = \lambda \vec{a} \) for some scalar \( \lambda \). If \( \vec{a} = a_1 \hat{i} + a_2 \hat{j} + a_3 \hat{k} \) and \( \vec{b} = b_1 \hat{i} + b_2 \hat{j} + b_3 \hat{k} \), then \( \frac{b_1}{a_1} = \frac{b_2}{a_2} = \frac{b_3}{a_3} = \lambda \).
Solution
- Step 1: Check statement (A): \( \vec{b} = \lambda \vec{a} \) for some scalar \( \lambda \). This is exactly the definition of collinear vectors. So statement (A) is CORRECT.
- Step 2: Check statement (B): \( \vec{a} = \pm \vec{b} \). This would force the scalar \( \lambda \) to be only \( +1 \) or \( -1 \), meaning the two vectors must have equal magnitudes. But collinear vectors can have different magnitudes, for example \( \vec{b} = 3\vec{a} \). Hence statement (B) is INCORRECT.
- Step 3: Check statement (C): the respective components of \( \vec{a} \) and \( \vec{b} \) are NOT proportional. For collinear vectors the components ARE proportional, since \( \vec{b} = \lambda \vec{a} \) gives \( \frac{b_1}{a_1} = \frac{b_2}{a_2} = \frac{b_3}{a_3} = \lambda \). This statement claims the opposite, so statement (C) is INCORRECT.
- Step 4: Check statement (D): both vectors have the same direction but different magnitudes. Collinear vectors need not point in the same direction; if \( \lambda < 0 \) they point in opposite directions. Since (D) insists on the SAME direction only, it does not describe all collinear vectors, so statement (D) is INCORRECT.
- Step 5: Collect the results. Only (A) correctly describes collinear vectors. Statements (B), (C) and (D) each fail for some collinear vectors, so they are the incorrect ones.
Final Answer
The incorrect statements are (B), (C) and (D). Only statement (A), namely \( \vec{b} = \lambda \vec{a} \) for some scalar \( \lambda \), correctly characterises collinear vectors.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is assuming collinear vectors must always point in the same direction or have equal magnitudes. In reality \( \lambda \) can be any scalar (positive, negative, or of any size), so collinear vectors can be oppositely directed and of different lengths.