SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
2023 Board Paper Q18

The probability that \(A\) speaks the truth is \(\dfrac{4}{5}\) and that of \(B\) speaking the truth is \(\dfrac{3}{4}.\) The probability that they contradict each other in stating the same fact is : (A)\(\dfrac{7}{20}\) (B)\(\dfrac{1}{5}\) (C)\(\dfrac{3}{20}\) (D)\(\dfrac{4}{5}\)

CBSE Class 12 Maths · Probability

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two friends, A and B, each flipping their own coin to decide whether to tell the truth. A contradiction happens when one tells the truth and the other tells a lie — like one coin showing heads while the other shows tails. Person A tells the truth most of the time, and so does B. We find the chance they disagree by adding two situations: A honest while B lies, plus A lying while B is honest. Those two chances add up to give the final answer.

Answer: The probability that A and B contradict each other is \( \dfrac{7}{20} \), so the correct option is (A).

📖 Probability of A and B Contradicting Each Other

Detailed Explanation

Two people 'contradict each other' when one of them tells the truth and the other tells a lie about the same fact. Since A and B speak independently, whatever A says does not affect whether B tells the truth. Contradiction happens in two mutually exclusive ways: (1) A speaks the truth and B lies, OR (2) A lies and B speaks the truth. We compute each case using the multiplication rule for independent events, then add them because the two cases cannot occur together.

Formula Used

For independent events, \( P(E \cap F) = P(E) \cdot P(F) \). Probability of contradiction: \[ P(\text{contradict}) = P(A)\,P(B') + P(A')\,P(B) \] where \( P(A') = 1 - P(A) \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down the given probabilities. The probability that A speaks the truth is \( P(A) = \dfrac{4}{5} \) and the probability that B speaks the truth is \( P(B) = \dfrac{3}{4} \).
  2. Step 2: Find the probability that each one lies (does not speak the truth). \[ P(A') = 1 - \frac{4}{5} = \frac{1}{5} \] \[ P(B') = 1 - \frac{3}{4} = \frac{1}{4} \]
  3. Step 3: Identify how a contradiction occurs. They contradict each other when exactly one of them tells the truth. This gives two cases: A truthful and B lying, or A lying and B truthful. Since A and B act independently, we multiply their probabilities in each case.
  4. Step 4: Compute the first case: A speaks the truth and B lies. \[ P(A)\,P(B') = \frac{4}{5} \times \frac{1}{4} = \frac{4}{20} \]
  5. Step 5: Compute the second case: A lies and B speaks the truth. \[ P(A')\,P(B) = \frac{1}{5} \times \frac{3}{4} = \frac{3}{20} \]
  6. Step 6: Add the two mutually exclusive cases to get the probability of contradiction. \[ P(\text{contradict}) = \frac{4}{20} + \frac{3}{20} = \frac{7}{20} \]

Final Answer

The probability that A and B contradict each other is \( \dfrac{7}{20} \), so the correct option is (A).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to compute the probability that both tell the truth or both lie (agreement) instead of contradiction, or to only take one case like \( P(A)\,P(B') \) and forget to add the second case \( P(A')\,P(B) \).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Note the given probabilities: \( P(A) = \dfrac{4}{5} \) (A speaks truth) and \( P(B) = \dfrac{3}{4} \) (B speaks truth). — Reason: Identifying what is given before computing anything avoids confusion later.
  2. Step 2: Find the probability that A lies: \[P(A') = 1 - \frac{4}{5} = \frac{1}{5}\] and the probability that B lies: \[P(B') = 1 - \frac{3}{4} = \frac{1}{4}\] — Reason: The complement rule gives us the lying probabilities directly from the truth-telling ones.
  3. Step 3: Recognise the two cases that produce a contradiction: (i) A tells the truth AND B lies, or (ii) A lies AND B tells the truth. — Reason: A contradiction means exactly one person reports correctly; these two cases are mutually exclusive, so their probabilities will be added.
  4. Step 4: Compute Case (i) — A speaks the truth and B lies. Since A and B act independently, multiply their probabilities: \[P(A) \times P(B') = \frac{4}{5} \times \frac{1}{4} = \frac{4}{20}\] — Reason: The multiplication rule applies because A's behaviour has no influence on B's behaviour.
  5. Step 5: Compute Case (ii) — A lies and B speaks the truth: \[P(A') \times P(B) = \frac{1}{5} \times \frac{3}{4} = \frac{3}{20}\] — Reason: Same independence argument; multiply the individual probabilities for this scenario.
  6. Step 6: Add the two cases to get the total probability of contradiction: \[P(\text{contradict}) = \frac{4}{20} + \frac{3}{20} = \frac{7}{20}\] — Reason: Since the two cases cannot happen simultaneously, the addition rule for mutually exclusive events applies.

Final Answer

The probability that A and B contradict each other is \( \dfrac{7}{20} \), so the correct option is (A).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students sometimes add \( P(A) + P(B) \) or \( P(A') + P(B') \) directly, forgetting that a contradiction requires exactly ONE person to lie — so you must multiply within each case first, then add the two resulting products.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: \(P(A) = \dfrac{4}{5},\; P(B) = \dfrac{3}{4},\; P(A') = \dfrac{1}{5},\; P(B') = \dfrac{1}{4}\)
  2. Step 2: \[P(\text{contradict}) = \frac{4}{5} \times \frac{1}{4} + \frac{1}{5} \times \frac{3}{4} = \frac{4}{20} + \frac{3}{20} = \frac{7}{20}\]

Answer: The probability that A and B contradict each other is \( \dfrac{7}{20} \), so the correct option is (A).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The probability that Ravi speaks the truth is \(\dfrac{2}{3}\) and the probability that Seema speaks the truth is \(\dfrac{3}{5}\). They are asked to report on the same event independently. Find the probability that they contradict each other.

Solution: Let R be the event that Ravi speaks the truth and S be the event that Seema speaks the truth. Given: \(P(R) = \dfrac{2}{3}\) and \(P(S) = \dfrac{3}{5}\). Therefore: \(P(R') = 1 - \dfrac{2}{3} = \dfrac{1}{3}\) and \(P(S') = 1 - \dfrac{3}{5} = \dfrac{2}{5}\). They contradict each other when Ravi speaks the truth and Seema lies, OR when Ravi lies and Seema speaks the truth. These two cases are mutually exclusive, so: \[P(\text{contradiction}) = P(R) \cdot P(S') + P(R') \cdot P(S)\] Substituting the values: \[P(\text{contradiction}) = \dfrac{2}{3} \times \dfrac{2}{5} + \dfrac{1}{3} \times \dfrac{3}{5}\] \[= \dfrac{4}{15} + \dfrac{3}{15}\] \[= \dfrac{7}{15}\]

Answer: \(\dfrac{7}{15}\)

Example 2

Question: In a court case, witness P tells the truth with probability \(\dfrac{5}{6}\) and witness Q tells the truth with probability \(\dfrac{7}{9}\). Both witnesses independently describe the same incident. What is the probability that their statements contradict each other?

Solution: Let the event that P speaks the truth be denoted by \(T_P\) and the event that Q speaks the truth be denoted by \(T_Q\). Given: \(P(T_P) = \dfrac{5}{6}\) and \(P(T_Q) = \dfrac{7}{9}\). Therefore: \(P(T_P') = 1 - \dfrac{5}{6} = \dfrac{1}{6}\) and \(P(T_Q') = 1 - \dfrac{7}{9} = \dfrac{2}{9}\). Contradiction occurs when exactly one of the two tells the truth. The two mutually exclusive cases are: Case 1: P tells the truth and Q lies. Case 2: P lies and Q tells the truth. \[P(\text{contradiction}) = P(T_P) \cdot P(T_Q') + P(T_P') \cdot P(T_Q)\] Substituting the values: \[P(\text{contradiction}) = \dfrac{5}{6} \times \dfrac{2}{9} + \dfrac{1}{6} \times \dfrac{7}{9}\] \[= \dfrac{10}{54} + \dfrac{7}{54}\] \[= \dfrac{17}{54}\]

Answer: \(\dfrac{17}{54}\)

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The probability that Riya speaks the truth is \( \dfrac{2}{3} \) and the probability that Sana speaks the truth is \( \dfrac{4}{5} \). They independently observe and report the same event. The probability that they contradict each other in their statements is: (A) \( \dfrac{2}{5} \) (B) \( \dfrac{2}{15} \) (C) \( \dfrac{7}{15} \) (D) \( \dfrac{8}{15} \)

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the given probabilities: Let P(R) = probability that Riya speaks the truth = \( \dfrac{2}{3} \). Therefore, probability that Riya lies = \( 1 - \dfrac{2}{3} = \dfrac{1}{3} \). Let P(S) = probability that Sana speaks the truth = \( \dfrac{4}{5} \). Therefore, probability that Sana lies = \( 1 - \dfrac{4}{5} = \dfrac{1}{5} \).
  2. Step 2: Identify the condition for contradiction: Riya and Sana contradict each other when exactly one of them tells the truth. This happens in two mutually exclusive cases: Case 1 — Riya tells the truth AND Sana lies. Case 2 — Riya lies AND Sana tells the truth.
  3. Step 3: Compute the probability of Case 1: P(Riya true and Sana lies) = P(Riya true) \( \times \) P(Sana lies) = \( \dfrac{2}{3} \times \dfrac{1}{5} = \dfrac{2}{15} \).
  4. Step 4: Compute the probability of Case 2: P(Riya lies and Sana true) = P(Riya lies) \( \times \) P(Sana true) = \( \dfrac{1}{3} \times \dfrac{4}{5} = \dfrac{4}{15} \).
  5. Step 5: Add the two cases: Since the two cases are mutually exclusive, the total probability of contradiction is \[ P(\text{contradiction}) = \dfrac{2}{15} + \dfrac{4}{15} = \dfrac{6}{15} = \dfrac{2}{5} \]
  6. Step 6: Select the correct option: The probability that Riya and Sana contradict each other is \( \dfrac{2}{5} \), which corresponds to option (A).

Answer: The probability that Riya and Sana contradict each other is \( \dfrac{2}{5} \), so the correct option is (A).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Probability

Chapter 13 Examples Q1 65/4/1 2022 / Section A Q1 Chapter 13 Examples Q2 65/4/1 2022 / Section A Q2(a) Chapter 13 Examples Q3 65/4/1 2022 / Section A Q2(b) 65/4/2 2024 / Section A Q3 Chapter 13 Examples Q4 65/2/3 2026 / Section A Q4 Chapter 13 Examples Q5 65/2/1 2022 / Section A Q4 Chapter 13 Examples Q6 65/2/1 2022 / Section A Q5 Chapter 13 Examples Q7 Chapter 13 Examples Q8 65/2/2 2023 / Section A Q8 Chapter 13 Examples Q9 Chapter 13 Examples Q10 Chapter 13 Examples Q11 65/1/1 2024 / Section A Q11 65/2/1 2024 / Section A Q11 65/3/1 2024 / Section A Q11 Chapter 13 Examples Q12 65/1/1 2023 / Section A Q12 Chapter 13 Examples Q13 Chapter 13 Examples Q14 65/3/1 2023 / Section A Q14 Chapter 13 Examples Q15 Chapter 13 Examples Q16 65(B) 2026 / Section A Q16 Chapter 13 Examples Q17 65(B) 2026 / Section A Q17 Chapter 13 Examples Q18 65(B) 2026 / Section A Q18 65/2/1 2022 / Section C Q14(a) 65/3/1 2026 / Section A Q18 65/4/1 2026 / Section A Q18 65/5/1 2026 / Section A Q18 Chapter 13 Examples Q19 65/1/1 2026 / Section A Q19 65/2/1 2022 / Section C Q14(b) 65/4/1 2022 / Section C Q14(a) Chapter 13 Examples Q20 65(B) 2026 / Section A Q20 65/4/1 2022 / Section C Q14(b) Chapter 13 Examples Q21 Chapter 13 Miscellaneous Examples Q22 Chapter 13 Miscellaneous Examples Q23 Chapter 13 Miscellaneous Examples Q24 Exercise 13.1 Q1 Exercise 13.1 Q2 Exercise 13.1 Q3(i) Exercise 13.1 Q3(ii) 65/2/3 2026 / Section C Q26(a)i Exercise 13.1 Q3(iii) 65/2/3 2026 / Section C Q26(a)ii Exercise 13.1 Q4 65/2/3 2026 / Section C Q26(b) Exercise 13.1 Q5(i) 65/2/2 2023 / Section C Q28(a)