Show that the matrix \(B′AB\) is symmetric or skew symmetric according as \(A\) is symmetric or skew symmetric.
CBSE Class 12 Maths · Matrices
CBSE Class 12 Maths · Matrices
Think of flipping a sandwich. If the original sandwich looks the same flipped, it is symmetric. If it looks like its mirror opposite, it is skew-symmetric. The matrix \( B^{T}AB \) inherits this flipping behaviour directly from \( A \). When we flip \( B^{T}AB \), the only part that changes is \( A \), which either stays the same or flips its sign. So whatever type \( A \) is, \( B^{T}AB \) turns out to be exactly the same type.
Answer: Since \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}A^{T}B \): if \( A^{T} = A \) (symmetric) then \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}AB \), so \( B^{T}AB \) is symmetric; if \( A^{T} = -A \) (skew-symmetric) then \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = -B^{T}AB \), so \( B^{T}AB \) is skew-symmetric. This proves the required result.
A square matrix \( A \) is called symmetric if \( A^{T} = A \), and skew-symmetric if \( A^{T} = -A \). Here \( B \) is any matrix (of suitable order so that the product \( B^{T}AB \) is defined). To determine whether \( B^{T}AB \) is symmetric or skew-symmetric, we compute its transpose \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} \) and compare it with \( B^{T}AB \) itself. The key tools are the reversal law of transpose, \( (XY)^{T} = Y^{T}X^{T} \), and the fact that the transpose of a transpose returns the original matrix, \( (B^{T})^{T} = B \). By substituting the condition on \( A \), we get either \( +B^{T}AB \) (symmetric) or \( -B^{T}AB \) (skew-symmetric).
\( (XY)^{T} = Y^{T}X^{T} \), \( (XYZ)^{T} = Z^{T}Y^{T}X^{T} \), \( (B^{T})^{T} = B \). Symmetric: \( A^{T} = A \); Skew-symmetric: \( A^{T} = -A \).
Since \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}A^{T}B \): if \( A^{T} = A \) (symmetric) then \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}AB \), so \( B^{T}AB \) is symmetric; if \( A^{T} = -A \) (skew-symmetric) then \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = -B^{T}AB \), so \( B^{T}AB \) is skew-symmetric. This proves the required result.
A common error is forgetting to reverse the order of the matrices when taking the transpose of a product, i.e. writing \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}A^{T}B^{T} \) or \( B A^{T} B^{T} \). The correct reversal law gives \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}A^{T}(B^{T})^{T} = B^{T}A^{T}B \); using the wrong order breaks the proof.
Since \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}A^{T}B \): if \( A^{T} = A \) (symmetric) then \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}AB \), so \( B^{T}AB \) is symmetric; if \( A^{T} = -A \) (skew-symmetric) then \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = -B^{T}AB \), so \( B^{T}AB \) is skew-symmetric. This proves the required result.
One common mistake: Students often write \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}A^{T}B^{T} \), forgetting that \( (B^{T})^{T} = B \) (not \( B^{T} \)), which leads to an incorrect expression and an invalid conclusion.
Answer: Since \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}A^{T}B \): if \( A^{T} = A \) (symmetric) then \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = B^{T}AB \), so \( B^{T}AB \) is symmetric; if \( A^{T} = -A \) (skew-symmetric) then \( (B^{T}AB)^{T} = -B^{T}AB \), so \( B^{T}AB \) is skew-symmetric. This proves the required result.
Question: Let A be any square matrix and P be any matrix such that the product \( P^T A P \) is defined. Show that \( P^T A P \) is symmetric if A is symmetric, and skew-symmetric if A is skew-symmetric.
Solution: Let Q = P^T A P. We need to find Q^T and compare it with Q. Computing Q^T: \[ Q^T = \left( P^T A P \right)^T \] Using the property \( (XYZ)^T = Z^T Y^T X^T \): \[ Q^T = P^T A^T \left( P^T \right)^T = P^T A^T P \] Case 1: A is symmetric, so \( A^T = A \). Substituting: \[ Q^T = P^T A P = Q \] Since \( Q^T = Q \), the matrix \( P^T A P \) is symmetric. Case 2: A is skew-symmetric, so \( A^T = -A \). Substituting: \[ Q^T = P^T (-A) P = -P^T A P = -Q \] Since \( Q^T = -Q \), the matrix \( P^T A P \) is skew-symmetric. Hence, \( P^T A P \) is symmetric when A is symmetric and skew-symmetric when A is skew-symmetric.
Answer: \( P^T A P \) is symmetric if A is symmetric, and skew-symmetric if A is skew-symmetric.
Question: If A is a \( 3 \times 3 \) symmetric matrix and C is any \( 3 \times n \) matrix, verify that the matrix \( C^T A C \) is also symmetric. Also state what happens when A is skew-symmetric.
Solution: Let M = C^T A C. We compute M^T to determine its symmetry. Taking transpose of M: \[ M^T = \left( C^T A C \right)^T \] Applying the rule \( (XYZ)^T = Z^T Y^T X^T \): \[ M^T = C^T A^T \left( C^T \right)^T \] Since \( \left( C^T \right)^T = C \): \[ M^T = C^T A^T C \] Case 1: A is symmetric, meaning \( A^T = A \). Then: \[ M^T = C^T A C = M \] Since \( M^T = M \), the matrix \( C^T A C \) is symmetric. Case 2: A is skew-symmetric, meaning \( A^T = -A \). Then: \[ M^T = C^T (-A) C = - C^T A C = -M \] Since \( M^T = -M \), the matrix \( C^T A C \) is skew-symmetric. Therefore, \( C^T A C \) is symmetric when A is symmetric, and skew-symmetric when A is skew-symmetric.
Answer: \( C^T A C \) is symmetric when A is symmetric; \( C^T A C \) is skew-symmetric when A is skew-symmetric.
Question: Let P be any matrix of appropriate order and let A be a square matrix. Prove that the matrix \( P^T A P \) is symmetric if A is symmetric, and skew-symmetric if A is skew-symmetric. Also verify your result for the specific case where \[ A = \begin{bmatrix} 0 & 3 \\ -3 & 0 \end{bmatrix} \] and \[ P = \begin{bmatrix} 1 & 2 \\ 0 & 1 \end{bmatrix}. \]
Answer: In general: \( (P^T A P)^T = P^T A^T P \). When A is symmetric (\( A^T = A \)), this gives \( (P^T A P)^T = P^T A P \), so \( P^T A P \) is symmetric. When A is skew-symmetric (\( A^T = -A \)), this gives \( (P^T A P)^T = -(P^T A P) \), so \( P^T A P \) is skew-symmetric. Verified explicitly: for the given skew-symmetric A and matrix P, \( P^T A P = \begin{bmatrix} 0 & 3 \\ -3 & 0 \end{bmatrix} \), which is skew-symmetric.