Example 1
Question: Let \(\Delta = \begin{vmatrix} b_{11} & b_{12} & b_{13} \\ b_{21} & b_{22} & b_{23} \\ b_{31} & b_{32} & b_{33} \end{vmatrix}\) and let \(B_{ij}\) denote the cofactor of \(b_{ij}\). Which of the following expressions correctly gives the value of \(\Delta\)? (A) \(b_{12}B_{11} + b_{22}B_{21} + b_{32}B_{31}\) (B) \(b_{21}B_{21} + b_{22}B_{22} + b_{23}B_{23}\) (C) \(b_{11}B_{12} + b_{12}B_{22} + b_{13}B_{32}\) (D) \(b_{31}B_{11} + b_{32}B_{12} + b_{33}B_{13}\)
Solution: The fundamental rule for determinant expansion states that \(\Delta\) equals the sum of products of the elements of any row (or column) with their OWN cofactors. Option (A): This multiplies elements of column 1 ( \(b_{12}, b_{22}, b_{32}\) are actually column 2 elements) with cofactors of column 1 — these belong to different columns, so this is a cross-column expansion and equals 0, not \(\Delta\). Option (B): This is the expansion along Row 2. Each element \(b_{2j}\) is multiplied by its own cofactor \(B_{2j}\). By the cofactor expansion theorem, this equals \(\Delta\). This is correct. Option (C): The elements \(b_{11}, b_{12}, b_{13}\) are from Row 1, but \(B_{12}, B_{22}, B_{32}\) are cofactors of Column 2 (different rows of column 2). This is a cross-expansion and equals 0. Option (D): The elements \(b_{31}, b_{32}, b_{33}\) belong to Row 3, but \(B_{11}, B_{12}, B_{13}\) are cofactors of Row 1. Since these rows differ, this cross-row expansion equals 0. Therefore, the correct answer is Option (B): \(b_{21}B_{21} + b_{22}B_{22} + b_{23}B_{23}\), which is the valid cofactor expansion along the second row.
Answer: (B) \(b_{21}B_{21} + b_{22}B_{22} + b_{23}B_{23}\)
Example 2
Question: Given \(\Delta = \begin{vmatrix} p & q & r \\ s & t & u \\ x & y & z \end{vmatrix}\), and \(P_{ij}\) is the cofactor of the element in position \((i, j)\), which of the following is equal to \(\Delta\)? (A) \(p \cdot P_{11} + s \cdot P_{21} + x \cdot P_{31}\) (B) \(p \cdot P_{21} + q \cdot P_{22} + r \cdot P_{23}\) (C) \(q \cdot P_{11} + t \cdot P_{21} + y \cdot P_{31}\) (D) \(s \cdot P_{11} + t \cdot P_{12} + u \cdot P_{13}\)
Solution: Label the matrix entries as follows. Row 1: \(a_{11}=p,\, a_{12}=q,\, a_{13}=r\). Row 2: \(a_{21}=s,\, a_{22}=t,\, a_{23}=u\). Row 3: \(a_{31}=x,\, a_{32}=y,\, a_{33}=z\). The cofactor expansion along Column 1 is: \[\Delta = a_{11}P_{11} + a_{21}P_{21} + a_{31}P_{31} = p \cdot P_{11} + s \cdot P_{21} + x \cdot P_{31}\] Now check each option: Option (A): \(p \cdot P_{11} + s \cdot P_{21} + x \cdot P_{31}\) — these are the Column 1 elements ( \(p, s, x\) ) multiplied by their own cofactors ( \(P_{11}, P_{21}, P_{31}\) ). This is a valid expansion along Column 1. This equals \(\Delta\). Option (B): \(p \cdot P_{21} + q \cdot P_{22} + r \cdot P_{23}\) — \(p, q, r\) are Row 1 elements, but \(P_{21}, P_{22}, P_{23}\) are Row 2 cofactors. This is a cross-row expansion and equals 0. Option (C): \(q \cdot P_{11} + t \cdot P_{21} + y \cdot P_{31}\) — \(q, t, y\) are Column 2 elements, but \(P_{11}, P_{21}, P_{31}\) are Column 1 cofactors. This is a cross-column expansion and equals 0. Option (D): \(s \cdot P_{11} + t \cdot P_{12} + u \cdot P_{13}\) — \(s, t, u\) are Row 2 elements, but \(P_{11}, P_{12}, P_{13}\) are Row 1 cofactors. This is a cross-row expansion and equals 0. Hence the correct answer is Option (A).
Answer: (A) \(p \cdot P_{11} + s \cdot P_{21} + x \cdot P_{31}\)