If \(^nC_9= ^nC_8,\) find \(^nC_{17}.\)
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Permutations and Combinations
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Permutations and Combinations
Imagine you have a magic choosing rule: picking 9 things from a bag gives the same result as picking 8 things. That can only happen when the total number of things in the bag equals 9 plus 8, which is 17. So the bag has 17 items. Now the question asks: how many ways can you pick all 17 things from a bag of 17? There is only one way — you simply take everything! That is why the answer is 1.
Answer: \( {}^{n}C_{17} = {}^{17}C_{17} = 1 \).
This problem uses a key property of combinations: if \( {}^{n}C_{a} = {}^{n}C_{b} \), then either \( a = b \) or \( a + b = n \). This happens because \( {}^{n}C_{r} = {}^{n}C_{n-r} \), meaning choosing r objects out of n is the same as leaving out \( n - r \) objects. Here the lower indices 9 and 8 are different, so they cannot be equal. Therefore we must use the second condition, \( a + b = n \), to find n. Once n is known, we compute the required combination using the same symmetry property to simplify the calculation.
\( {}^{n}C_{r} = {}^{n}C_{n-r} \), and if \( {}^{n}C_{a} = {}^{n}C_{b} \) then \( a = b \) or \( a + b = n \).
\( {}^{n}C_{17} = {}^{17}C_{17} = 1 \).
A common mistake is to set \( 9 = 8 \) or to forget the symmetry property entirely, and thus fail to find \( n = 17 \). Another error is thinking \( {}^{17}C_{17} \) is undefined instead of correctly getting 1, since \( 0! = 1 \).
\( {}^{n}C_{17} = {}^{17}C_{17} = 1 \).
One common mistake: Students sometimes try to set \( 9 = 8 \) directly to find \( n \), forgetting that the correct approach when the two lower indices differ is to use the sum condition \( a + b = n \), not \( a = b \).
Answer: \( {}^{n}C_{17} = {}^{17}C_{17} = 1 \).
Question: If \( {}^{n}C_{12} = {}^{n}C_{5} \), find \( {}^{n}C_{17} \).
Solution: We are given \( {}^{n}C_{12} = {}^{n}C_{5} \). Using the property: if \( {}^{n}C_{r} = {}^{n}C_{s} \), then either \( r = s \) or \( r + s = n \). Here \( r = 12 \) and \( s = 5 \), and since \( 12 \ne 5 \), we use the second case: \[ r + s = n \] \[ 12 + 5 = n \] \[ n = 17 \] Now we need to find \( {}^{17}C_{17} \). Recall that \( {}^{n}C_{n} = 1 \) for any non-negative integer \( n \). Therefore: \[ {}^{17}C_{17} = 1 \]
Answer: \( {}^{n}C_{17} = {}^{17}C_{17} = 1 \)
Question: If \( {}^{n}C_{6} = {}^{n}C_{10} \), find the value of \( {}^{n}C_{16} \).
Solution: We are given \( {}^{n}C_{6} = {}^{n}C_{10} \). Using the property: if \( {}^{n}C_{r} = {}^{n}C_{s} \), then either \( r = s \) or \( r + s = n \). Here \( r = 6 \) and \( s = 10 \), and since \( 6 \ne 10 \), we use: \[ r + s = n \] \[ 6 + 10 = n \] \[ n = 16 \] Now we need to find \( {}^{16}C_{16} \). Using the identity \( {}^{n}C_{n} = 1 \): \[ {}^{16}C_{16} = 1 \] We can verify this using the formula: \[ {}^{16}C_{16} = \frac{16!}{16! \cdot 0!} = \frac{16!}{16! \cdot 1} = 1 \]
Answer: \( {}^{n}C_{16} = {}^{16}C_{16} = 1 \)
Question: If \( {}^{n}C_{12} = {}^{n}C_{6} \), find the value of \( {}^{n}C_{18} \).
Answer: \( {}^{n}C_{18} = {}^{18}C_{18} = 1 \), where \( n = 18 \).