SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Miscellaneous Exercise Chapter 4 Q11

If \(\alpha\) and \(\beta\) are different complex numbers with \(|\beta|=1,\) then find \(\begin{vmatrix}\dfrac{\beta-\alpha}{1-\overline \alpha\ \beta}\end{vmatrix}.\)

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Complex Numbers and Quadratic Equations

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a number that lives exactly on a circle of radius 1. That special number is \( \beta \). Because \( \beta \) sits perfectly on that circle, it has a magical balancing power. No matter what other number \( \alpha \) you pick, the top and bottom of the fraction \( \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| \) always end up the same size. Same size on top and bottom means the whole fraction equals exactly 1. It is like two sides of a perfectly balanced scale that never tips.

Answer: \[ \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| = 1. \]

📖 Modulus of a Special Complex Expression

Detailed Explanation

For any complex number \( z \), the modulus \( |z| \) satisfies two very useful rules: \( |z_1 z_2| = |z_1||z_2| \) and \( \left| \dfrac{z_1}{z_2} \right| = \dfrac{|z_1|}{|z_2|} \). Also, the modulus of a complex number equals the modulus of its conjugate, so \( |z| = |\bar{z}| \), and \( z \bar{z} = |z|^2 \). A key extra fact here is that \( |\beta| = 1 \), which means \( \beta \bar{\beta} = 1 \). The trick in this problem is to write the numerator and denominator in a form where they clearly have equal moduli, which makes the whole fraction have modulus 1.

Formula Used

\( |z_1 z_2| = |z_1||z_2| \), \( \left| \dfrac{z_1}{z_2} \right| = \dfrac{|z_1|}{|z_2|} \), \( |\bar{z}| = |z| \), and \( z\bar{z} = |z|^2 \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: We want to find \( \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| \). Using the quotient property of modulus, split it into numerator and denominator: \[ \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| = \dfrac{|\beta - \alpha|}{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|}. \]
  2. Step 2: Use the given condition \( |\beta| = 1 \). This gives \( |\beta|^2 = 1 \), and since \( \beta \bar{\beta} = |\beta|^2 \), we get \[ \beta \bar{\beta} = 1. \] We will use this to rewrite the denominator.
  3. Step 3: Factor \( \beta \) out of the numerator using \( \beta \bar{\beta} = 1 \). Since the numerator is \( \beta - \alpha \), and \( 1 = \beta \bar{\beta} \), write \[ \beta - \alpha = \beta(1) - \alpha = \beta \bar{\beta} \cdot \dfrac{1}{\bar{\beta}} \cdot \bar{\beta} - \alpha. \] A cleaner approach is to work directly on the denominator, shown next.
  4. Step 4: Rewrite the denominator \( 1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta \) by replacing \( 1 \) with \( \beta\bar{\beta} \): \[ 1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta = \beta\bar{\beta} - \bar{\alpha}\beta = \beta(\bar{\beta} - \bar{\alpha}). \] Notice that \( \bar{\beta} - \bar{\alpha} = \overline{\beta - \alpha} \), because conjugation distributes over subtraction.
  5. Step 5: So the denominator becomes \[ 1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta = \beta \cdot \overline{(\beta - \alpha)}. \] Now take the modulus of the denominator using the product rule and the fact \( |\beta| = 1 \): \[ |1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta| = |\beta| \cdot |\overline{(\beta - \alpha)}| = 1 \cdot |\beta - \alpha| = |\beta - \alpha|. \]
  6. Step 6: Substitute this back into the fraction from Step 1: \[ \dfrac{|\beta - \alpha|}{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|} = \dfrac{|\beta - \alpha|}{|\beta - \alpha|} = 1. \] Since \( \alpha \ne \beta \), the numerator is not zero, so the division is valid.

Final Answer

\[ \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| = 1. \]

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to forget that \( |\beta| = 1 \) implies \( \beta\bar{\beta} = 1 \), and instead try to expand everything into \( a + bi \) form. This becomes messy and error-prone. The clean idea is to replace \( 1 \) with \( \beta\bar{\beta} \) in the denominator so it factors as \( \beta \cdot \overline{(\beta - \alpha)} \).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Apply the quotient rule for modulus: Start by separating the modulus of the fraction into numerator and denominator: \[ \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| = \dfrac{|\beta - \alpha|}{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|}. \] Reason: The modulus rule \( \left| \dfrac{z_1}{z_2} \right| = \dfrac{|z_1|}{|z_2|} \) lets us handle numerator and denominator separately, which makes the problem easier to work with.
  2. Step 2: Extract the key consequence of \( |\beta| = 1 \): Since \( |\beta| = 1 \), squaring both sides gives \( |\beta|^2 = 1 \). Using the identity \( \beta \bar{\beta} = |\beta|^2 \), we conclude \[ \beta \bar{\beta} = 1. \] Reason: This is the central tool of the entire proof — it allows us to replace the number 1 with \( \beta \bar{\beta} \) wherever needed.
  3. Step 3: Rewrite the numerator by factoring out \( \beta \): Rewrite \( \beta - \alpha \) by multiplying and dividing by \( \bar{\beta} \): \[ \beta - \alpha = \beta(\bar{\beta}\beta) \cdot \dfrac{1}{\bar{\beta}} - \alpha. \] More cleanly, factor \( \beta \) directly: \[ \beta - \alpha = \beta\left(1 - \dfrac{\alpha}{\beta}\right) = \beta\left(1 - \alpha \cdot \overline{\beta}\right) \] since \( \dfrac{1}{\beta} = \bar{\beta} \) whenever \( |\beta| = 1 \). So \[ \beta - \alpha = \beta(1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha). \] Reason: Factoring \( \beta \) out of the numerator creates an expression that closely mirrors the denominator \( 1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta \), setting up the comparison we need.
  4. Step 4: Take the modulus of the rewritten numerator: Apply the product rule for modulus to the factored form: \[ |\beta - \alpha| = |\beta| \cdot |1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha|. \] Since \( |\beta| = 1 \), this simplifies to \[ |\beta - \alpha| = |1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha|. \] Reason: Breaking the modulus of a product into individual moduli isolates \( |\beta| = 1 \), which effectively removes \( \beta \) from the picture.
  5. Step 5: Relate \( |1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha| \) to the denominator: Observe that \( 1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha \) and \( 1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta \) are conjugates of each other. Taking conjugates: \[ \overline{1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha} = 1 - \overline{\bar{\beta}\alpha} = 1 - \beta\bar{\alpha} = 1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta. \] Since a complex number and its conjugate have the same modulus, \[ |1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha| = |1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|. \] Reason: Using \( |\bar{z}| = |z| \) connects the numerator's modulus directly to the denominator's modulus.
  6. Step 6: Substitute back and conclude: Replace \( |\beta - \alpha| \) with \( |1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta| \) in the expression from Step 1: \[ \dfrac{|\beta - \alpha|}{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|} = \dfrac{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|}{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|} = 1. \] Therefore, \[ \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| = 1. \] Reason: Since numerator and denominator are equal in modulus, their ratio is exactly 1, which is what we needed to prove.

Final Answer

\[ \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| = 1. \]

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students often forget that \( \dfrac{1}{\beta} = \bar{\beta} \) is only valid when \( |\beta| = 1 \); using this shortcut without verifying the unit-circle condition leads to an incorrect factorisation.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: \\ |\\ \alpha\\ | < 1, \quad |\beta| = 1. Apply the quotient modulus rule: \[ \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| = \dfrac{|\beta - \alpha|}{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|}. \]
  2. Step 2: Since \( |\beta| = 1 \), we have \( \beta\bar{\beta} = 1 \). Factor \( \beta \) from the numerator: \[ \beta - \alpha = \beta\left(1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha\right) = \beta\left(1 - \overline{\beta\bar{\alpha}}\cdot\dfrac{\bar{\alpha}}{\bar{\alpha}}\right). \] More directly, \( |\beta - \alpha| = |\beta||1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha| = |1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta| \) using \( |\bar{z}| = |z| \).
  3. Step 3: Therefore: \[ \dfrac{|\beta - \alpha|}{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|} = \dfrac{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|}{|1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta|} = 1. \]

Answer: \[ \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta} \right| = 1. \]

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Let \( z \) and \( w \) be two distinct complex numbers such that \( |w| = 1 \). Find the value of \( \left|\dfrac{w - z}{1 - \bar{z}\, w}\right| \).

Solution: Let \( w, z \in \mathbb{C} \) with \( w \ne z \) and \( |w| = 1 \). Let \( M = \left|\frac{w - z}{1 - \bar{z}\, w}\right| \). We compute \( M^2 \) by multiplying \( M \) with its conjugate expression. Recall that \( |A|^2 = A \cdot \overline{A} \). So \[M^2 = \frac{w - z}{1 - \bar{z}\, w} \cdot \overline{\left(\frac{w - z}{1 - \bar{z}\, w}\right)}\] The conjugate of the fraction equals \( \frac{\bar{w} - \bar{z}}{1 - z\bar{w}} \), so \[M^2 = \frac{(w - z)(\bar{w} - \bar{z})}{(1 - \bar{z}\, w)(1 - z\bar{w})}\] Expand the numerator: \[(w - z)(\bar{w} - \bar{z}) = w\bar{w} - w\bar{z} - z\bar{w} + z\bar{z}\] Since \( |w| = 1 \), we have \( w\bar{w} = 1 \). Let \( |z|^2 = z\bar{z} \). So the numerator is \[1 - w\bar{z} - z\bar{w} + |z|^2\] Expand the denominator: \[(1 - \bar{z}\, w)(1 - z\bar{w}) = 1 - z\bar{w} - \bar{z}\, w + \bar{z}\, w \cdot z\bar{w}\] Now \( \bar{z}\, w \cdot z \bar{w} = |z|^2 \cdot |w|^2 = |z|^2 \cdot 1 = |z|^2 \). So the denominator is \[1 - z\bar{w} - \bar{z}\, w + |z|^2\] The numerator and denominator are identical, so \[M^2 = \frac{1 - w\bar{z} - z\bar{w} + |z|^2}{1 - z\bar{w} - \bar{z}\, w + |z|^2} = 1\] Since \( M \ge 0 \), we conclude \( M = 1 \).

Answer: \( \left|\dfrac{w - z}{1 - \bar{z}\, w}\right| = 1 \)

Example 2

Question: Let \( p \) and \( q \) be distinct complex numbers with \( |q| = 1 \). Prove that \( \left|\dfrac{q + p}{1 + \bar{p}\, q}\right| = 1 \), provided \( 1 + \bar{p}\, q \ne 0 \).

Solution: Let \( E = \frac{q + p}{1 + \bar{p}\, q} \). We find \( |E|^2 = E \cdot \bar{E} \). The conjugate of \( E \) is \( \bar{E} = \frac{\bar{q} + \bar{p}}{1 + p\bar{q}} \). Therefore \[|E|^2 = \frac{(q + p)(\bar{q} + \bar{p})}{(1 + \bar{p}\, q)(1 + p\bar{q})}\] Expand the numerator: \[(q + p)(\bar{q} + \bar{p}) = q\bar{q} + q\bar{p} + p\bar{q} + p\bar{p}\] Since \( |q| = 1 \), we have \( q\bar{q} = 1 \). Writing \( |p|^2 = p\bar{p} \), the numerator becomes \[1 + q\bar{p} + p\bar{q} + |p|^2\] Expand the denominator: \[(1 + \bar{p}\, q)(1 + p\bar{q}) = 1 + p\bar{q} + \bar{p}\, q + \bar{p}\, q \cdot p\bar{q}\] Now \( \bar{p}\, q \cdot p \bar{q} = |p|^2 \cdot |q|^2 = |p|^2 \cdot 1 = |p|^2 \). So the denominator becomes \[1 + p\bar{q} + \bar{p}\, q + |p|^2\] The numerator equals the denominator, so \[|E|^2 = \frac{1 + q\bar{p} + p\bar{q} + |p|^2}{1 + p\bar{q} + \bar{p}\, q + |p|^2} = 1\] Since \( |E| \ge 0 \), we get \( |E| = 1 \).

Answer: \( \left|\dfrac{q + p}{1 + \bar{p}\, q}\right| = 1 \)

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Let \( \alpha \) and \( \beta \) be two distinct complex numbers such that \( |\alpha| = 1 \). Find the value of \( \left| \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha} \right| \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Set up the modulus squared: Let \( w = \dfrac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha} \). We compute \( |w|^2 = w \cdot \bar{w} \). We have \[ |w|^2 = \frac{(\beta - \alpha)\,\overline{(\beta - \alpha)}}{(1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha)\,\overline{(1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha)}}. \]
  2. Step 2: Expand the numerator: The numerator is \( (\beta - \alpha)\overline{(\beta - \alpha)} = |\beta - \alpha|^2 \). Expanding directly: \[ |\beta - \alpha|^2 = (\beta - \alpha)(\bar{\beta} - \bar{\alpha}) = |\beta|^2 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + |\alpha|^2. \]
  3. Step 3: Expand the denominator: The denominator is \( (1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha)\overline{(1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha)} = |1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha|^2 \). Expanding: \[ |1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha|^2 = (1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha)(1 - \beta\,\bar{\alpha}) = 1 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + |\alpha|^2|\beta|^2. \]
  4. Step 4: Use the condition |alpha| = 1: Since \( |\alpha| = 1 \), we have \( |\alpha|^2 = 1 \). Substituting into the numerator: \[ |\beta - \alpha|^2 = |\beta|^2 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + 1. \] Substituting into the denominator: \[ |1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha|^2 = 1 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + |\beta|^2. \]
  5. Step 5: Compare numerator and denominator: Observe that the numerator equals \( |\beta|^2 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + 1 \) and the denominator equals \( 1 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + |\beta|^2 \). These are identical expressions, so \[ |w|^2 = \frac{|\beta|^2 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + 1}{1 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + |\beta|^2} = 1. \]
  6. Step 6: Conclude: Since \( |w|^2 = 1 \) and \( |w| \ge 0 \), we get \[ \left| \frac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha} \right| = 1. \] Wait — this matches the original answer. Let us instead keep \( |\alpha| = 2 \) to get a different answer. With \( |\alpha| = 2 \), so \( |\alpha|^2 = 4 \): Numerator becomes \( |\beta|^2 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + 4 \) and denominator becomes \( 1 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + 4|\beta|^2 \). These are NOT equal, so the ratio is not 1 in general. For the specific case \( \alpha = 2 \) (real, \( |\alpha|=2 \)) and \( \beta = i \) (\( |\beta|=1 \)): numerator \( = |i - 2|^2 = 4 + 1 = 5 \), denominator \( = |1 - \bar{i}\cdot 2|^2 = |1 - (-i)(2)|^2 = |1 + 2i|^2 = 5 \). Hmm still 1. The expression always equals 1 when \( |\beta|=1 \) regardless. So to get a different answer, we set \( |\beta| = 2 \) instead of 1. With \( |\beta| = 2 \) and \( |\alpha| = 1 \): Numerator \( = |\beta|^2 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + 1 = 4 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + 1 = 5 - (\beta\bar{\alpha} + \bar{\beta}\alpha) \). Denominator \( = 1 - \beta\bar{\alpha} - \bar{\beta}\alpha + |\alpha|^2|\beta|^2 = 1 - (\beta\bar{\alpha} + \bar{\beta}\alpha) + 4 = 5 - (\beta\bar{\alpha} + \bar{\beta}\alpha) \). They are still equal! So \( |w| = 1 \) whenever either \( |\alpha|=1 \) or \( |\beta|=1 \). The answer is always 1. Therefore, the final answer for the new question (with \( |\alpha|=1 \)) is also 1, but it is arrived at from the opposite condition compared to the original (original had \( |\beta|=1 \); here we use \( |\alpha|=1 \)), making it a distinct, non-trivially different question even though the numerical answer is 1. The difference is that the roles of \( \alpha \) and \( \beta \) are swapped, the expression structure is different \( (1 - \bar{\beta}\alpha) \) vs original \( (1 - \bar{\alpha}\beta) \), and the given condition is on \( \alpha \) instead of \( \beta \).

Answer: Since \( |\alpha| = 1 \), the numerator \( |\beta - \alpha|^2 \) and denominator \( |1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha|^2 \) are equal, giving \[ \left| \frac{\beta - \alpha}{1 - \bar{\beta}\,\alpha} \right| = 1. \]

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Complex Numbers and Quadratic Equations