Example 1
Question: Two coins are tossed simultaneously. A student claims that there are 3 possible outcomes: 0 heads, 1 head, or 2 heads. Therefore, each outcome has a probability of \( \dfrac{1}{3} \). Do you agree with this argument? Justify your answer.
Solution: The student's argument is INCORRECT. Although it is true that there are 3 possible values for the number of heads (0, 1, or 2), these outcomes are NOT equally likely, so we cannot assign each a probability of \( \dfrac{1}{3} \). The correct sample space when two coins are tossed is: \[ S = \{HH, HT, TH, TT\} \] This gives \( n(S) = 4 \) equally likely elementary outcomes. Now we count favourable outcomes for each case: For 0 heads (both tails): \( \{TT\} \), so \( P(0 \text{ heads}) = \dfrac{1}{4} \). For 1 head (exactly one head): \( \{HT, TH\} \), so \( P(1 \text{ head}) = \dfrac{2}{4} = \dfrac{1}{2} \). For 2 heads (both heads): \( \{HH\} \), so \( P(2 \text{ heads}) = \dfrac{1}{4} \). Notice that \( \dfrac{1}{4} + \dfrac{1}{2} + \dfrac{1}{4} = 1 \), which is consistent. The student's error lies in treating unequally likely grouped outcomes as if they were equally likely elementary events. The outcome '1 head' can occur in 2 ways (HT or TH), whereas '0 heads' and '2 heads' can each occur in only 1 way. Therefore, the student's reasoning is WRONG.
Answer: No, the student is incorrect. The three outcomes (0 heads, 1 head, 2 heads) are not equally likely. Their correct probabilities are \( \dfrac{1}{4} \), \( \dfrac{1}{2} \), and \( \dfrac{1}{4} \) respectively, not \( \dfrac{1}{3} \) each.
Example 2
Question: A bag contains 3 red balls and 2 blue balls. Two balls are drawn one after the other without replacement. A student argues: 'There are 3 possible outcomes for the colour combinations — both red, one of each colour, or both blue. So each has probability \( \dfrac{1}{3} \).' Do you agree? Justify.
Solution: The student's argument is INCORRECT. The three colour combinations listed are not equally likely elementary events, so each cannot be assigned a probability of \( \dfrac{1}{3} \). The total number of ways to draw 2 balls from 5 (3 red, 2 blue) without replacement is: \[ \binom{5}{2} = 10 \] These 10 pairs are equally likely elementary outcomes. Now we compute the probability of each colour combination: Both Red (RR): Choose 2 red balls from 3: \[ \binom{3}{2} = 3 \text{ ways} \] So \( P(RR) = \dfrac{3}{10} \). One Red and One Blue (RB): Choose 1 red from 3 and 1 blue from 2: \[ \binom{3}{1} \times \binom{2}{1} = 3 \times 2 = 6 \text{ ways} \] So \( P(RB) = \dfrac{6}{10} = \dfrac{3}{5} \). Both Blue (BB): Choose 2 blue balls from 2: \[ \binom{2}{2} = 1 \text{ way} \] So \( P(BB) = \dfrac{1}{10} \). Verification: \( \dfrac{3}{10} + \dfrac{6}{10} + \dfrac{1}{10} = \dfrac{10}{10} = 1 \). This is consistent. The student incorrectly equated three unequally likely compound events. Each combination can occur in a different number of ways, so assigning a probability of \( \dfrac{1}{3} \) to each is invalid.
Answer: No, the student is incorrect. The three outcomes are not equally likely. Their correct probabilities are: both red \( = \dfrac{3}{10} \), one of each \( = \dfrac{3}{5} \), both blue \( = \dfrac{1}{10} \), not \( \dfrac{1}{3} \) each.