SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 14.1 Q22(ii)

A die is thrown once. A student argues that ‘there are 11 possible outcomes 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12. Therefore, each of them has a probability\(\dfrac{1}{11}\) . Do you agree with this argument? Justify your answer.

CBSE Class 10 Maths · Probability

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you have two dice. When you roll them, some totals show up way more often than others. Getting a total of 7 is much easier than getting a 2 or a 12. Think of it like a lucky raffle where some numbers have many tickets and others have just one. A student said every total has an equal chance — but that is wrong! There are 36 different ways the dice can land, and the totals do not share those 36 ways equally.

Answer: No, the student's argument is incorrect. The 11 possible sums (2 to 12) are not equally likely outcomes. The correct sample space consists of 36 equally likely ordered pairs. Each sum has a different probability — for example, P(sum = 2) = 1/36 and P(sum = 7) = 6/36 = 1/6.

📖 Two Dice Thrown Once — Analysing a Faulty Probability Argument

Detailed Explanation

The student's claim is that when two dice are thrown, there are 11 possible outcomes (sums from 2 to 12), so each has probability \(\dfrac{1}{11}\). This reasoning is incorrect.

The key rule of classical probability is: all outcomes in the sample space must be equally likely before we can divide 1 equally among them. The 11 sums are not equally likely.

The correct sample space consists of all ordered pairs (a, b) where \( a \) is the result of the first die and \( b \) is the result of the second die. This gives \(6 \times 6 = 36\) equally likely outcomes.

Formula Used

\[P(\text{Event}) = \dfrac{\text{Number of favourable outcomes}}{\text{Total number of equally likely outcomes}}\]

This formula is valid only when all outcomes are equally likely.

Solution

  1. Total equally likely outcomes:
    Each die has 6 faces. So total outcomes \(= 6 \times 6 = 36\).
  2. Count favourable outcomes for each sum:
    Sum Ways to get it Number of ways
    2(1,1)1
    3(1,2),(2,1)2
    4(1,3),(2,2),(3,1)3
    5(1,4),(2,3),(3,2),(4,1)4
    6(1,5),(2,4),(3,3),(4,2),(5,1)5
    7(1,6),(2,5),(3,4),(4,3),(5,2),(6,1)6
    8(2,6),(3,5),(4,4),(5,3),(6,2)5
    9(3,6),(4,5),(5,4),(6,3)4
    10(4,6),(5,5),(6,4)3
    11(5,6),(6,5)2
    12(6,6)1
  3. Are the sums equally likely?
    No. Sum 7 has 6 favourable outcomes while sum 2 has only 1. So they have different probabilities.
  4. Correct probabilities (examples):
    \[P(\text{sum} = 2) = \dfrac{1}{36}\]
    \[P(\text{sum} = 7) = \dfrac{6}{36} = \dfrac{1}{6}\] These are clearly not equal to \(\dfrac{1}{11}\).

Final Answer

No, we do not agree with the student's argument. The 11 possible sums (2 to 12) are not equally likely. The true sample space has 36 equally likely outcomes. Each sum has a different probability depending on how many ordered pairs give that sum. Therefore, it is wrong to assign each sum a probability of \(\dfrac{1}{11}\).

Common Mistake

Students often look at the number of distinct values a result can take and assume each is equally probable. Remember: equal probability requires equally likely outcomes. Always build the full sample space of ordered pairs first, then count favourable cases.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what the student claimed.
    Reason: We need to pinpoint exactly where the student's logic went wrong before correcting it.
    The student said: there are 11 possible sums (2, 3, 4, …, 12) when two dice are thrown, so each sum has probability \(\dfrac{1}{11}\).
  2. Step 2: Check the key condition for using the equal-probability formula.
    Reason: The formula \(P = \dfrac{\text{favourable outcomes}}{\text{total outcomes}}\) is valid only when every outcome is equally likely. If outcomes are not equally likely, we cannot simply divide 1 by the number of outcomes.
    Question to ask: Are the 11 sums equally likely? — We will verify this in the next steps.
  3. Step 3: Build the correct sample space.
    Reason: Instead of listing sums, we must list every possible ordered pair \((a, b)\), where \(a\) = result on die 1 and \(b\) = result on die 2. Each such pair is equally likely because each face of a fair die has probability \(\dfrac{1}{6}\).
    \[\text{Total outcomes} = 6 \times 6 = 36 \text{ equally likely ordered pairs}\]
  4. Step 4: Count how many ordered pairs give the sum 2.
    Reason: Sum = 2 only when both dice show 1, i.e., the pair \((1,1)\).
    Favourable outcomes = 1
    \[P(\text{sum} = 2) = \dfrac{1}{36}\]
  5. Step 5: Count how many ordered pairs give the sum 7.
    Reason: Sum = 7 can happen in multiple ways — \((1,6),\ (2,5),\ (3,4),\ (4,3),\ (5,2),\ (6,1)\).
    Favourable outcomes = 6
    \[P(\text{sum} = 7) = \dfrac{6}{36} = \dfrac{1}{6}\]
  6. Step 6: Compare the two probabilities to expose the flaw.
    Reason: If all 11 sums were equally likely (as the student claimed), every sum would have the same probability. But we just showed:
    \[P(\text{sum} = 2) = \dfrac{1}{36} \neq \dfrac{1}{6} = P(\text{sum} = 7)\]
    This directly disproves the student's assumption that the 11 sums are equally likely.
  7. Step 7: State the correct conclusion.
    Reason: Since the 11 sums are NOT equally likely, the student cannot assign probability \(\dfrac{1}{11}\) to each. The correct approach is to use the 36 equally likely ordered pairs as the sample space and count favourable pairs for each event.
    The student's argument is therefore incorrect.

Final Answer

No, the student's argument is incorrect. The 11 possible sums (2 to 12) are not equally likely outcomes. The correct sample space consists of 36 equally likely ordered pairs. Each sum has a different probability — for example, P(sum = 2) = 1/36 and P(sum = 7) = 6/36 = 1/6.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students confuse 'number of possible outcomes' with 'number of equally likely outcomes.' Just because a sum can take 11 different values does not mean each value is equally likely — you must always verify the equal-likelihood condition before applying the classical probability formula.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

Total outcomes \(= 6 \times 6 = 36\) equally likely ordered pairs \((a,\, b)\).

\(P(\text{sum} = 2) = \dfrac{1}{36}\)  |  \(P(\text{sum} = 7) = \dfrac{6}{36} = \dfrac{1}{6}\)

Sums 2–12 are not equally likely \(\Rightarrow P(\text{each sum}) \neq \dfrac{1}{11}\).

Answer: No, the student's argument is incorrect. The 11 possible sums (2 to 12) are not equally likely outcomes. The correct sample space consists of 36 equally likely ordered pairs. Each sum has a different probability — for example, P(sum = 2) = 1/36 and P(sum = 7) = 6/36 = 1/6.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Two coins are tossed simultaneously. A student claims that there are 3 possible outcomes: 0 heads, 1 head, or 2 heads. Therefore, each outcome has a probability of \( \dfrac{1}{3} \). Do you agree with this argument? Justify your answer.

Solution: The student's argument is INCORRECT. Although it is true that there are 3 possible values for the number of heads (0, 1, or 2), these outcomes are NOT equally likely, so we cannot assign each a probability of \( \dfrac{1}{3} \). The correct sample space when two coins are tossed is: \[ S = \{HH, HT, TH, TT\} \] This gives \( n(S) = 4 \) equally likely elementary outcomes. Now we count favourable outcomes for each case: For 0 heads (both tails): \( \{TT\} \), so \( P(0 \text{ heads}) = \dfrac{1}{4} \). For 1 head (exactly one head): \( \{HT, TH\} \), so \( P(1 \text{ head}) = \dfrac{2}{4} = \dfrac{1}{2} \). For 2 heads (both heads): \( \{HH\} \), so \( P(2 \text{ heads}) = \dfrac{1}{4} \). Notice that \( \dfrac{1}{4} + \dfrac{1}{2} + \dfrac{1}{4} = 1 \), which is consistent. The student's error lies in treating unequally likely grouped outcomes as if they were equally likely elementary events. The outcome '1 head' can occur in 2 ways (HT or TH), whereas '0 heads' and '2 heads' can each occur in only 1 way. Therefore, the student's reasoning is WRONG.

Answer: No, the student is incorrect. The three outcomes (0 heads, 1 head, 2 heads) are not equally likely. Their correct probabilities are \( \dfrac{1}{4} \), \( \dfrac{1}{2} \), and \( \dfrac{1}{4} \) respectively, not \( \dfrac{1}{3} \) each.

Example 2

Question: A bag contains 3 red balls and 2 blue balls. Two balls are drawn one after the other without replacement. A student argues: 'There are 3 possible outcomes for the colour combinations — both red, one of each colour, or both blue. So each has probability \( \dfrac{1}{3} \).' Do you agree? Justify.

Solution: The student's argument is INCORRECT. The three colour combinations listed are not equally likely elementary events, so each cannot be assigned a probability of \( \dfrac{1}{3} \). The total number of ways to draw 2 balls from 5 (3 red, 2 blue) without replacement is: \[ \binom{5}{2} = 10 \] These 10 pairs are equally likely elementary outcomes. Now we compute the probability of each colour combination: Both Red (RR): Choose 2 red balls from 3: \[ \binom{3}{2} = 3 \text{ ways} \] So \( P(RR) = \dfrac{3}{10} \). One Red and One Blue (RB): Choose 1 red from 3 and 1 blue from 2: \[ \binom{3}{1} \times \binom{2}{1} = 3 \times 2 = 6 \text{ ways} \] So \( P(RB) = \dfrac{6}{10} = \dfrac{3}{5} \). Both Blue (BB): Choose 2 blue balls from 2: \[ \binom{2}{2} = 1 \text{ way} \] So \( P(BB) = \dfrac{1}{10} \). Verification: \( \dfrac{3}{10} + \dfrac{6}{10} + \dfrac{1}{10} = \dfrac{10}{10} = 1 \). This is consistent. The student incorrectly equated three unequally likely compound events. Each combination can occur in a different number of ways, so assigning a probability of \( \dfrac{1}{3} \) to each is invalid.

Answer: No, the student is incorrect. The three outcomes are not equally likely. Their correct probabilities are: both red \( = \dfrac{3}{10} \), one of each \( = \dfrac{3}{5} \), both blue \( = \dfrac{1}{10} \), not \( \dfrac{1}{3} \) each.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Two dice are thrown simultaneously. A student claims: 'The possible products of the two numbers shown are 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 12, 15, 16, 18, 20, 24, 25, 30, 36 — that is 18 possible values. So each product has probability \(\dfrac{1}{18}\).' Do you agree with this argument? Justify your answer.

Solution

  1. Correct Sample Space: When two dice are thrown simultaneously, each die has 6 faces. The total number of equally likely outcomes (ordered pairs) is \(6 \times 6 = 36\). For example: (1,1), (1,2), ..., (6,6).
  2. Examine the Student's Claim: The student lists 18 distinct product values and assigns each a probability of \(\dfrac{1}{18}\). This assumes all 18 products are equally likely — but they are not.
  3. Show Different Products Have Different Probabilities:
    • Product = 1: Only (1,1) → 1 outcome → \(P = \dfrac{1}{36}\)
    • Product = 6: Outcomes (1,6), (6,1), (2,3), (3,2) → 4 outcomes → \(P = \dfrac{4}{36} = \dfrac{1}{9}\)
    • Product = 36: Only (6,6) → 1 outcome → \(P = \dfrac{1}{36}\)
  4. Conclusion: The student's argument is incorrect. Merely listing distinct product values does not make them equally likely. The valid sample space consists of 36 equally likely ordered pairs, and different product values occur with different frequencies.

Answer: No, the student's argument is incorrect. The 18 distinct product values are not equally likely. The correct sample space has 36 equally likely ordered pairs, and probabilities differ by product — for example, \(P(\text{product} = 1) = \dfrac{1}{36}\) while \(P(\text{product} = 6) = \dfrac{4}{36} = \dfrac{1}{9}\).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Probability

Chapter 14 Examples Q1 Chapter 14 Examples Q2(i) 30/2/1 2026 / Section A Q2 Chapter 14 Examples Q2(ii) 430/4/1 2024 / Section A Q3 430/5/1 2023 / Section A Q3 Chapter 14 Examples Q2(iii) Chapter 14 Examples Q3(i) 430/4/1 2026 / Section A Q5 430/5/1 2024 / Section A Q5 Chapter 14 Examples Q3(ii) Chapter 14 Examples Q4(i) 30/2/1 2023 / Section A Q7 Chapter 14 Examples Q4(ii) 430/3/1 2024 / Section A Q8 Chapter 14 Examples Q5 430/2/1 2023 / Section A Q9 Chapter 14 Examples Q6(i) Chapter 14 Examples Q6(ii) 30/2/1 2023 / Section A Q11 30/2/1 2026 / Section A Q11 30/4/1 2023 / Section A Q11 Chapter 14 Examples Q7(i) 430/4/1 2026 / Section A Q12 Chapter 14 Examples Q7(ii) 30/1/1 2026 / Section A Q13 Chapter 14 Examples Q8(i) 30/3/1 2026 / Section A Q14 430/2/1 2023 / Section A Q14 430/3/1 2024 / Section A Q14 Chapter 14 Examples Q8(ii) 30/5/1 2023 / Section A Q15 Chapter 14 Examples Q8(iii) Chapter 14 Examples Q9 30/5/1 2023 / Section A Q17 Chapter 14 Examples Q10 30/4/1 2023 / Section A Q18 430/1/1 2026 / Section A Q18 430/2/1 2026 / Section A Q18 430/3/1 2026 / Section A Q18 CBSE-ADDL1 2024 / Section A Q18 CBSE-ADDL2 2024 / Section A Q18 Chapter 14 Examples Q11 30/1/1 2026 / Section A Q19 30/4/1 2023 / Section A Q19 430/5/1 2023 / Section A Q19 430/5/1 2024 / Section A Q19 Chapter 14 Examples Q12(i) 430/2/1 2023 / Section A Q20 430/4/1 2024 / Section A Q20 430/4/1 2026 / Section A Q20 CBSE-ADDL1 2024 / Section A Q20 Chapter 14 Examples Q12(ii) Chapter 14 Examples Q13(i) 30/3/1 2026 / Section B Q22 Chapter 14 Examples Q13(ii) 430/4/1 2026 / Section B Q23(a) Chapter 14 Examples Q13(iii) 430/4/1 2026 / Section B Q23(b)i Exercise 14.1 Q1(i)