Detailed Explanation
This problem uses the fundamental relationship between distance, speed, and time: Distance = Speed × Time. When two people walk towards each other, their speeds add up (relative speed = sum of speeds). When they walk in the same direction, the faster person gains on the slower one (relative speed = difference of speeds). We translate both situations into equations and solve them simultaneously.
Formula Used
Distance = Speed × Time
Let the two speeds be \( u \) km/h and \( v \) km/h (with \( u > v \)).
Walking towards each other: \[ (u + v) \times 2 = 16 \]
Walking in the same direction: \[ (u - v) \times 8 = 16 \]
Solution
- Step 1 – Assign Variables: Let the speed of the faster person be \( u \) km/h and the speed of the slower person be \( v \) km/h, where \( u > v \).
- Step 2 – Set Up Equation 1 (Walking Towards Each Other): When two people walk towards each other, they cover the total gap between them together. Their combined speed is \( u + v \). They meet in 2 hours, and the total distance is 16 km. So: \[ (u + v) \times 2 = 16 \]
Dividing both sides by 2: \[ u + v = 8 \quad \text{...(i)} \]
- Step 3 – Set Up Equation 2 (Walking in the Same Direction): When they walk in the same direction, the faster person gains on the slower person. The effective closing speed is \( u - v \). They meet in 8 hours, covering the 16 km gap. So: \[ (u - v) \times 8 = 16 \]
Dividing both sides by 8: \[ u - v = 2 \quad \text{...(ii)} \]
- Step 4 – Solve the System of Equations: We now have two equations:
Equation (i): \( u + v = 8 \)
Equation (ii): \( u - v = 2 \)
Adding both equations: \[ (u + v) + (u - v) = 8 + 2 \] \[ 2u = 10 \] \[ u = 5 \]
Substituting \( u = 5 \) into equation (i): \[ 5 + v = 8 \] \[ v = 3 \]
- Step 5 – Verify the Answer: Check with both conditions:
Towards each other: combined speed \( = 5 + 3 = 8 \) km/h. Time \( = \frac{16}{8} = 2 \) hours. ✓
Same direction: relative speed \( = 5 - 3 = 2 \) km/h. Time \( = \frac{16}{2} = 8 \) hours. ✓
Both conditions are satisfied.
Final Answer
The walking speeds are \( u = 5 \) km/h and \( v = 3 \) km/h.
Common Mistake
A common mistake is adding the speeds for the same-direction case instead of subtracting them. Remember: when moving in the same direction, one person is gaining on the other, so the effective speed is the difference \( u - v \), not the sum \( u + v \).