How many terms of the arithmetic progression 45, 39, 33, ........ must be taken so that their sum is 180 ? Explain the double answer.
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Arithmetic Progressions
CBSE Class 10 Maths · Arithmetic Progressions
Imagine you are collecting coins every day, but each day you collect fewer coins than the day before. You start with 45 coins, then 39, then 33, and so on — losing 6 coins each day. At some point your total reaches 180 coins. But later days you actually owe coins, so your total dips and then climbs back to 180 again. Just like a seesaw going up, past the middle, and swinging back to the middle from the other side, the total hits 180 twice.
Answer: The number of terms required is \(n = 6\) or \(n = 10\). Both answers are correct. The sum equals 180 after 6 terms and again after 10 terms, because the 7th and 8th terms (positive) are exactly cancelled by the 9th and 10th terms (negative), making the sum return to 180.
An Arithmetic Progression (AP) is a sequence where the difference between consecutive terms is constant. Here, the terms are 45, 39, 33, ... so the first term is \(a = 45\) and the common difference is \(d = 39 - 45 = -6\). The sum of the first \(n\) terms of an AP is found using the sum formula. When we set this sum equal to 180 and solve, we get a quadratic equation, which can have two solutions. Both solutions are valid because in this AP the terms eventually become negative, meaning some later terms subtract from the sum — so the sum can equal 180 at two different points.
Sum of first n terms of an AP: \(S_n = \frac{n}{2}[2a + (n-1)d]\) where \(a\) is the first term and \(d\) is the common difference.
The number of terms required is \(n = 6\) or \(n = 10\). Both answers are correct. The sum equals 180 after 6 terms and again after 10 terms, because the 7th and 8th terms (positive) are exactly cancelled by the 9th and 10th terms (negative), making the sum return to 180.
Many students discard one of the two solutions thinking only one answer is possible. In AP sum problems, when terms become negative, the sum can first increase and then decrease, so it is possible for the sum to equal the same value at two different points. Always check both solutions to see if they are valid positive integers.
The number of terms required is \(n = 6\) or \(n = 10\). Both answers are correct. The sum equals 180 after 6 terms and again after 10 terms, because the 7th and 8th terms (positive) are exactly cancelled by the 9th and 10th terms (negative), making the sum return to 180.
One common mistake: students reject the second solution \(n = 10\) without checking it, assuming a quadratic can only have one meaningful answer in a word problem — but when terms of the AP turn negative, the sum genuinely returns to the same value a second time, so both solutions must be reported.
Answer: The number of terms required is \(n = 6\) or \(n = 10\). Both answers are correct. The sum equals 180 after 6 terms and again after 10 terms, because the 7th and 8th terms (positive) are exactly cancelled by the 9th and 10th terms (negative), making the sum return to 180.
Question: How many terms of the arithmetic progression 63, 57, 51, 48, … must be taken so that their sum is 273? Explain the double answer.
Solution: The AP is 63, 57, 51, … Here the first term is \(a = 63\) and the common difference is \(d = 57 - 63 = -6\).
We need \(S_n = 273\).
Using the sum formula: \[S_n = \frac{n}{2}\bigl(2a + (n-1)d\bigr)\]
Substituting the known values: \[273 = \frac{n}{2}\bigl(2(63) + (n-1)(-6)\bigr)\]
Simplifying inside the bracket: \[273 = \frac{n}{2}\bigl(126 - 6n + 6\bigr)\] \[273 = \frac{n}{2}\bigl(132 - 6n\bigr)\]
Multiplying both sides by 2: \[546 = n(132 - 6n)\]
Expanding: \[546 = 132n - 6n^2\]
Rearranging: \[6n^2 - 132n + 546 = 0\]
Dividing throughout by 6: \[n^2 - 22n + 91 = 0\]
Factorising: \[(n - 7)(n - 13) = 0\]
So \(n = 7\) or \(n = 13\).
Explanation of double answer: Both values of \(n\) are valid. The 8th term is \(a + 7d = 63 + 7 \times (-6) = 63 - 42 = 21\), still positive, but from the 11th term onward the terms become negative. Specifically, the 11th term is \(63 + 10(-6) = 3\) and the 12th term is \(63 + 11(-6) = -3\). The terms from the 8th to the 13th include both positive and negative values, and the negative terms from the 8th to the 13th exactly cancel the extra positive sum, making \(S_7 = S_{13} = 273\).
Answer: \(n = 7\) or \(n = 13\)
Question: A student saves money each week. The amounts saved form an AP: Rs. 50, Rs. 45, Rs. 40, … How many weeks must pass for the total savings to reach Rs. 300? Explain if there is more than one answer.
Solution: The AP is 50, 45, 40, … Here the first term is \(a = 50\) and the common difference is \(d = 45 - 50 = -5\).
We need \(S_n = 300\).
Using the sum formula: \[S_n = \frac{n}{2}\bigl(2a + (n-1)d\bigr)\]
Substituting the known values: \[300 = \frac{n}{2}\bigl(2(50) + (n-1)(-5)\bigr)\]
Simplifying inside the bracket: \[300 = \frac{n}{2}\bigl(100 - 5n + 5\bigr)\] \[300 = \frac{n}{2}\bigl(105 - 5n\bigr)\]
Multiplying both sides by 2: \[600 = n(105 - 5n)\]
Expanding: \[600 = 105n - 5n^2\]
Rearranging: \[5n^2 - 105n + 600 = 0\]
Dividing throughout by 5: \[n^2 - 21n + 120 = 0\]
Factorising: \[(n - 8)(n - 15) = 0\]
So \(n = 8\) or \(n = 15\).
Explanation of double answer: Both answers are mathematically valid. After week 11, the weekly savings become negative (the student starts spending more than saving). The 11th term is \(50 + 10 \times (-5) = 0\) and from week 12 the amounts are negative. The negative contributions from weeks 9 through 15 exactly cancel the extra amount accumulated beyond Rs. 300, so the total after 8 weeks equals the total after 15 weeks, both giving Rs. 300. In a practical context, \(n = 8\) is the more meaningful answer unless negative savings (withdrawals) are allowed.
Answer: \(n = 8\) or \(n = 15\)
Question: How many terms of the arithmetic progression 63, 57, 51, ... must be taken so that their sum is 693? Explain the double answer if it arises.
Answer: For the AP 63, 57, 51, ... with sum \( S_n = 336 \), the number of terms required is \( n = 8 \) or \( n = 14 \). Both answers are correct. The sum reaches 336 after 8 terms and again after 14 terms, because the 9th through 14th terms (which are positive and negative in pairs) cancel each other out completely, leaving the total unchanged.