SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 7.2 Q4(ii)

\(ABC\) is a triangle in which altitudes \(BE\) and \(CF\) to sides \(AC\) and \(AB\) are equal (see Fig. 7.32). Show that \(AB=AC, i.e., ABC\) is an isosceles triangle.

CBSE Class 9 Maths · Triangles

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two friends each holding one end of the same stick, and both standing perfectly straight up. If both friends are exactly the same height, the stick must be balanced and the triangle they form is symmetric. Here, triangle ABC has two special lines called altitudes, and we are told they are equal. Because both altitudes meet the sides at right angles and share the same base \( BC \), the two smaller triangles formed are mirror images of each other. Mirror image triangles have equal matching parts, so the two sides of the big triangle must be equal, making it isosceles.

Answer: By RHS congruence, \( \triangle BEC \cong \triangle CFB \), which gives \( \angle ABC = \angle ACB \). Therefore \( AB = AC \), and so \( \triangle ABC \) is an isosceles triangle.

📖 Proving ABC is Isosceles Using Equal Altitudes

Detailed Explanation

An altitude of a triangle is a perpendicular drawn from a vertex to the opposite side. Here \( BE \perp AC \) and \( CF \perp AB \), so both \( \angle BEC \) and \( \angle BFC \) are right angles \( (90^\circ) \). To prove two sides of a triangle are equal, a very reliable method is to find two congruent triangles that contain those sides as corresponding parts. Since we have right angles, an equal altitude, and a shared side, the RHS (Right angle - Hypotenuse - Side) congruence criterion is the perfect tool. Once the triangles are proved congruent, the equal sides follow by CPCT (Corresponding Parts of Congruent Triangles).

Formula Used

RHS congruence criterion: Two right triangles are congruent if the hypotenuse and one side of one triangle are equal to the hypotenuse and one side of the other. Also used: CPCT (Corresponding Parts of Congruent Triangles are equal).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the right angles: Since \( BE \) is an altitude to \( AC \), we have \( BE \perp AC \), so \( \angle BEC = 90^\circ \). Since \( CF \) is an altitude to \( AB \), we have \( CF \perp AB \), so \( \angle CFB = 90^\circ \).
  2. Step 2: Choose two triangles to compare: Consider the two right triangles \( \triangle BEC \) and \( \triangle CFB \). Both are right-angled, both contain the altitudes given equal, and they share the common side \( BC \). This makes them ideal for the RHS test.
  3. Step 3: List the equal parts: In \( \triangle BEC \) and \( \triangle CFB \): \[ \angle BEC = \angle CFB = 90^\circ \] Given that the altitudes are equal: \[ BE = CF \] The side \( BC \) is common to both triangles (this side is the hypotenuse of each right triangle): \[ BC = CB \]
  4. Step 4: Apply the RHS congruence criterion: We have a right angle in each, equal hypotenuses \( BC = CB \), and one equal side \( BE = CF \). Therefore, by the RHS rule: \[ \triangle BEC \cong \triangle CFB \]
  5. Step 5: Use CPCT to get equal sides: Since the triangles are congruent, their corresponding parts are equal. The side \( EC \) corresponds to \( FB \), and by comparing angles we get \[ \angle BCE = \angle CBF \] These are the angles \( \angle ACB \) and \( \angle ABC \) of \( \triangle ABC \), so \[ \angle ABC = \angle ACB \]
  6. Step 6: Conclude that the sides are equal: In \( \triangle ABC \), the sides opposite equal angles are equal. Since \( \angle ABC = \angle ACB \), the sides opposite them are equal: the side opposite \( \angle ABC \) is \( AC \) and the side opposite \( \angle ACB \) is \( AB \). Hence \[ AB = AC \]

Final Answer

By RHS congruence, \( \triangle BEC \cong \triangle CFB \), which gives \( \angle ABC = \angle ACB \). Therefore \( AB = AC \), and so \( \triangle ABC \) is an isosceles triangle.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to try to prove \( \triangle ABE \cong \triangle ACF \) using AAS but forgetting that the equal altitudes \( BE \) and \( CF \) are non-hypotenuse sides, or incorrectly treating \( BC \) as an ordinary side instead of the hypotenuse. Always match the right angle, hypotenuse, and one side correctly when using RHS, and remember \( BC \) is common (not two different sides).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Recognise the right angles formed by the altitudes. Since \( BE \) is an altitude from \( B \) to side \( AC \), it meets \( AC \) perpendicularly, giving \( \angle BEC = 90^\circ \). Similarly, since \( CF \) is an altitude from \( C \) to side \( AB \), it meets \( AB \) perpendicularly, giving \( \angle CFB = 90^\circ \). — Reason: Altitudes are perpendicular to the sides they land on, so both triangles we are about to compare contain a right angle.
  2. Step 2: Pick the correct pair of triangles to compare. We focus on \( \triangle BEC \) and \( \triangle CFB \). Both are right-angled triangles (one at \( E \), the other at \( F \)), and both share the same side \( BC \). — Reason: Choosing triangles that already share a side and both have a right angle makes the RHS criterion easier to apply.
  3. Step 3: Identify the hypotenuse in each triangle. In \( \triangle BEC \), the side opposite the right angle at \( E \) is \( BC \). In \( \triangle CFB \), the side opposite the right angle at \( F \) is also \( BC \). Therefore the hypotenuse of both triangles is \( BC \), so the hypotenuses are equal. — Reason: For the RHS rule we must confirm which side is the hypotenuse; it is always the side opposite the right angle.
  4. Step 4: List all three matching conditions needed for RHS. In \( \triangle BEC \) and \( \triangle CFB \): First, \( \angle BEC = \angle CFB \) since both equal \( 90^\circ \). Second, \( BC = BC \) (the hypotenuse is common to both triangles). Third, \( BE = CF \) since the two altitudes are given to be equal. — Reason: RHS requires a right angle, an equal hypotenuse, and one equal side; we now have all three.
  5. Step 5: Apply the RHS congruence criterion. Since \( \angle BEC = \angle CFB = 90^\circ \), hypotenuse \( BC = BC \), and side \( BE = CF \), by the RHS criterion we conclude \( \triangle BEC \cong \triangle CFB \). — Reason: All three conditions of RHS are satisfied, so the two triangles are fully congruent.
  6. Step 6: Use CPCT to extract the equal angles. Because \( \triangle BEC \cong \triangle CFB \), all corresponding parts are equal. The angle at vertex \( C \) in \( \triangle BEC \) corresponds to the angle at vertex \( B \) in \( \triangle CFB \), giving \( \angle BCE = \angle CBF \), which means \( \angle BCA = \angle ABC \), i.e. \( \angle ACB = \angle ABC \). — Reason: CPCT lets us transfer congruence of triangles into congruence of specific angles or sides.
  7. Step 7: Conclude that triangle \( ABC \) is isosceles. Since \( \angle ABC = \angle ACB \), the sides opposite these equal angles must also be equal, so \( AC = AB \), i.e. \( AB = AC \). A triangle with two equal sides is isosceles by definition. — Reason: In any triangle, sides opposite equal angles are equal (a standard theorem on isosceles triangles).

Final Answer

By RHS congruence, \( \triangle BEC \cong \triangle CFB \), which gives \( \angle ABC = \angle ACB \). Therefore \( AB = AC \), and so \( \triangle ABC \) is an isosceles triangle.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students sometimes try to use the SAS or SSS criterion instead of RHS, and then struggle because they do not know all three sides. Since right angles are present, RHS is the most direct criterion and should be the first choice.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Identify right angles: \( BE \perp AC \Rightarrow \angle BEC = 90^\circ \); \( CF \perp AB \Rightarrow \angle CFB = 90^\circ \)
  2. Step 2: Establish equal parts in the two right triangles: In \( \triangle BEC \) and \( \triangle CFB \): \( \angle BEC = \angle CFB = 90^\circ \) (right angles); \( BC = BC \) (common hypotenuse); \( BE = CF \) (given equal altitudes)
  3. Step 3: Apply RHS and use CPCT: By RHS, \( \triangle BEC \cong \triangle CFB \), so \( \angle ABC = \angle ACB \) by CPCT, giving \( AB = AC \).

Answer: By RHS congruence, \( \triangle BEC \cong \triangle CFB \), which gives \( \angle ABC = \angle ACB \). Therefore \( AB = AC \), and so \( \triangle ABC \) is an isosceles triangle.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: In triangle \( \triangle PQR \), altitudes \( QM \) and \( RN \) are drawn to sides \( PR \) and \( PQ \) respectively. If \( QM = RN \), prove that \( PQ = PR \), i.e., \( \triangle PQR \) is isosceles.

Solution: We are given that in \( \triangle PQR \), \( QM \perp PR \) and \( RN \perp PQ \), and \( QM = RN \). Consider triangles \( \triangle PQM \) and \( \triangle PRN \). Since \( QM \) is an altitude to \( PR \), we have \( \angle PMQ = 90^\circ \). Since \( RN \) is an altitude to \( PQ \), we have \( \angle PNR = 90^\circ \). Therefore \( \angle PMQ = \angle PNR = 90^\circ \). The hypotenuses are \( PQ \) (in \( \triangle PQM \)) and \( PR \) (in \( \triangle PRN \))... but wait — we do not yet know \( PQ = PR \), so let us instead use AAS. In \( \triangle PQM \) and \( \triangle PRN \): First, \( \angle QMP = \angle RNP \) (each equal to \( 90^\circ \)). Second, \( \angle QPM = \angle RPM \), i.e., \( \angle P \) is common to both triangles. Third, \( QM = RN \) (given). By the AAS congruence rule (two angles and the side opposite to one of those angles are equal), we conclude: \[ \triangle PQM \cong \triangle PRN \] By CPCT (Corresponding Parts of Congruent Triangles): \[ PQ = PR \] Hence \( \triangle PQR \) is isosceles.

Answer: \( PQ = PR \); hence \( \triangle PQR \) is isosceles (proved using AAS congruence and CPCT).

Example 2

Question: In \( \triangle XYZ \), perpendiculars \( YA \) and \( ZB \) are drawn from vertices \( Y \) and \( Z \) to the opposite sides \( XZ \) and \( XY \) respectively. If \( YA = ZB \), show that \( \triangle XYZ \) is isosceles with \( XY = XZ \).

Solution: We are given that \( YA \perp XZ \) and \( ZB \perp XY \), and \( YA = ZB \). Consider triangles \( \triangle XYA \) and \( \triangle XZB \). Since \( YA \) is the altitude to \( XZ \): \( \angle XAY = 90^\circ \). Since \( ZB \) is the altitude to \( XY \): \( \angle XBZ = 90^\circ \). Therefore \( \angle XAY = \angle XBZ \) (both equal \( 90^\circ \)). Also, \( \angle X \) is the common angle shared by \( \triangle XYA \) and \( \triangle XZB \), so \( \angle YXA = \angle ZXB \). Finally, \( YA = ZB \) (given) — these are the sides opposite to the common angle \( \angle X \) in the respective triangles. By the AAS congruence rule (angle \( \angle XAY = \angle XBZ \), angle \( \angle X \) common, and the side \( YA = ZB \) opposite the common angle): \[ \triangle XYA \cong \triangle XZB \] By CPCT: \[ XY = XZ \] Hence \( \triangle XYZ \) is isosceles.

Answer: \( XY = XZ \); hence \( \triangle XYZ \) is isosceles (proved using AAS congruence and CPCT).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: In triangle \( \triangle PQR \), the perpendicular from vertex \( Q \) to side \( PR \) meets \( PR \) at \( M \), and the perpendicular from vertex \( R \) to side \( PQ \) meets \( PQ \) at \( N \). It is given that \( QM = RN \). Show that \( PQ = PR \), i.e., triangle \( \triangle PQR \) is isosceles.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the right angles: Since \( QM \perp PR \), we have \( \angle QMP = 90^\circ \). Since \( RN \perp PQ \), we have \( \angle RNP = 90^\circ \). So in triangles \( \triangle QMP \) and \( \triangle RNP \), both have a right angle at \( M \) and \( N \) respectively.
  2. Step 2: List the known equal parts: In \( \triangle QMP \) and \( \triangle RNP \): First, \( \angle QMP = \angle RNP = 90^\circ \) (right angles as identified above). Second, \( QM = RN \) (given). Third, \( QP = RP \)? — we cannot assume this yet, so instead note that \( PQ \) is the hypotenuse of \( \triangle RNP \) and \( PR \) is the hypotenuse of \( \triangle QMP \). We need a common element: the side \( PQ \) is shared as the hypotenuse. Wait — let us re-examine the triangles carefully.
  3. Step 3: Choose the correct pair of triangles: Consider \( \triangle QMR \) and \( \triangle RNQ \). In \( \triangle QMR \): \( \angle QMR = 90^\circ \) (since \( QM \perp PR \)), hypotenuse is \( QR \). In \( \triangle RNQ \): \( \angle RNQ = 90^\circ \) (since \( RN \perp PQ \)), hypotenuse is \( QR \). So both triangles are right-angled, and they share the same hypotenuse \( QR \).
  4. Step 4: Apply the RHS Congruence Rule: In \( \triangle QMR \) and \( \triangle RNQ \): \( \angle QMR = \angle RNQ = 90^\circ \) (right angles). Hypotenuse \( QR = QR \) (common side). \( QM = RN \) (given). By the RHS congruence rule, \( \triangle QMR \cong \triangle RNQ \).
  5. Step 5: Derive the equal angles: Since \( \triangle QMR \cong \triangle RNQ \) (by RHS), corresponding parts of congruent triangles are equal (CPCT). Therefore \( \angle MQR = \angle NRQ \), which means \( \angle PQR = \angle PRQ \).
  6. Step 6: Conclude that the triangle is isosceles: In \( \triangle PQR \), since \( \angle PQR = \angle PRQ \), the sides opposite to these equal angles must be equal. The side opposite \( \angle PQR \) is \( PR \), and the side opposite \( \angle PRQ \) is \( PQ \). Therefore \( PQ = PR \), and \( \triangle PQR \) is an isosceles triangle.

Answer: By RHS congruence, \( \triangle QMR \cong \triangle RNQ \), which gives \( \angle PQR = \angle PRQ \) by CPCT. Therefore \( PQ = PR \), and so \( \triangle PQR \) is an isosceles triangle.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Triangles