Examine each statement below and find out if it is ‘Always True’, ‘Only Sometimes True’, or ‘Never True’. Explain your reasoning. \(q^{46}\) is both a \(4\ th\) power and a \(6\ th\) power (\(q\) is a prime number).
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Power Play
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Power Play
Imagine you have a tower of blocks where the number of blocks is \( q^{46} \). To call it a 4th power, you must be able to split 46 evenly into groups of 4. But \( 46 \div 4 \) leaves a remainder, so you cannot. To call it a 6th power, you must split 46 evenly into groups of 6. But \( 46 \div 6 \) also leaves a remainder. Since neither split works out evenly, \( q^{46} \) is neither a 4th power nor a 6th power.
Answer: Never True. Since \( 46 \) is not divisible by 4 or by 6, \( q^{46} \) is neither a 4th power nor a 6th power for any prime \( q \).
A number is a '4th power' if it can be written as (something)^4, and a '6th power' if it can be written as (something)^6. For a prime power like \( q^{46} \), the base is fixed, so we only need to check whether the exponent 46 can be split correctly. \( q^{46} \) is a 4th power only if \( 46 \) is a multiple of 4, because \( (q^{k})^{4} = q^{4k} \). Similarly, \( q^{46} \) is a 6th power only if \( 46 \) is a multiple of 6, because \( (q^{m})^{6} = q^{6m} \). So the whole question reduces to checking the divisibility of the exponent 46 by 4 and by 6.
\( (a^{m})^{n} = a^{mn} \), so \( q^{46} \) is an n-th power only if \( n \) divides \( 46 \).
Never True. Since \( 46 \) is not divisible by 4 or by 6, \( q^{46} \) is neither a 4th power nor a 6th power for any prime \( q \).
A common mistake is thinking the answer depends on the value of the prime \( q \). It does not — only the exponent 46 matters. Whether 46 is a multiple of 4 or 6 stays the same for every prime, so the statement is 'Never True', not 'Only Sometimes True'.
Never True. Since \( 46 \) is not divisible by 4 or by 6, \( q^{46} \) is neither a 4th power nor a 6th power for any prime \( q \).
One common mistake: Students check whether 46 itself is a perfect 4th or 6th power (e.g. trying to compute \( \sqrt[4]{46} \)) instead of checking whether the exponent 46 is divisible by 4 or 6. For a prime power \( q^{46} \), only the divisibility of the exponent matters.
Answer: Never True. Since \( 46 \) is not divisible by 4 or by 6, \( q^{46} \) is neither a 4th power nor a 6th power for any prime \( q \).
Question: Examine the statement: \( p^{36} \) is both a perfect cube and a perfect 4th power, where \( p \) is a prime number. Is this statement 'Always True', 'Only Sometimes True', or 'Never True'? Explain your reasoning.
Solution: We need to check whether \( p^{36} \) can always be expressed as a perfect cube and also as a perfect 4th power. Checking for a perfect cube: A number is a perfect cube if its exponent (when written as a power of a prime) is divisible by 3. Here the exponent is 36. We check: \[ 36 \div 3 = 12 \] Since 36 is divisible by 3, we can write \( p^{36} = (p^{12})^{3} \), so \( p^{36} \) is always a perfect cube. Checking for a perfect 4th power: A number is a perfect 4th power if its exponent is divisible by 4. We check: \[ 36 \div 4 = 9 \] Since 36 is divisible by 4, we can write \( p^{36} = (p^{9})^{4} \), so \( p^{36} \) is always a perfect 4th power. Since both conditions hold for ANY prime \( p \) (the result depends only on the exponent 36, not on the value of \( p \)), the statement is Always True.
Answer: Always True. Since 36 is divisible by both 3 and 4, \( p^{36} = (p^{12})^{3} = (p^{9})^{4} \) for every prime \( p \).
Question: Examine the statement: \( m^{30} \) is both a perfect square and a perfect 9th power, where \( m \) is a prime number. Is this statement 'Always True', 'Only Sometimes True', or 'Never True'? Explain your reasoning.
Solution: We need to check whether \( m^{30} \) can always be expressed as a perfect square and also as a perfect 9th power. Checking for a perfect square: A number is a perfect square if its exponent is divisible by 2. The exponent here is 30. We check: \[ 30 \div 2 = 15 \] Since 30 is divisible by 2, we can write \( m^{30} = (m^{15})^{2} \), so \( m^{30} \) is always a perfect square. Checking for a perfect 9th power: A number is a perfect 9th power if its exponent is divisible by 9. We check: \[ 30 \div 9 = 3 \text{ remainder } 3 \] Since 30 is NOT divisible by 9 (because \( 9 \times 3 = 27 \ne 30 \)), \( m^{30} \) cannot be written as \( (\text{integer})^{9} \) when \( m \) is a prime. Therefore, although \( m^{30} \) is always a perfect square, it is NEVER a perfect 9th power (for any prime \( m \)). The combined statement is Never True.
Answer: Never True. While 30 is divisible by 2 (so \( m^{30} \) is always a perfect square), 30 is not divisible by 9, so \( m^{30} \) can never be a perfect 9th power for any prime \( m \).
Question: Examine the statement below and decide whether it is 'Always True', 'Only Sometimes True', or 'Never True'. Give clear reasoning. \( p^{36} \) is both a perfect cube and a perfect 4th power, where \( p \) is a prime number.
Answer: Always True. Because both 3 and 4 divide 36 exactly, \( p^{36} = \left( p^{12} \right)^3 \) is always a perfect cube and \( p^{36} = \left( p^{9} \right)^4 \) is always a perfect 4th power, for every prime \( p \).