SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q11(ii)

Karim was taking a nap under a tree. He had a dream about a magical lamp and a genie. He heard a voice saying, “I have come to serve you, Oh master”. He woke up and to his surprise, it was a genie! “Do you want to make money?”, asked the genie. Karim nodded dumbly in bewilderment. The genie continued, “Do you see the banyan tree over there\(?\) All you have to do is go around it once. The money in your pocket will double”. Karim immediately started towards the tree, only to be stopped by the genie. “One moment!”, said the genie. “Since I am bringing you great riches, you should share some of your gains with me. You must give me \(8\) coins each time you go around the tree.” Thinking that was a trifling amount, Karim readily agreed. He went around the tree once. Just as the genie had said, the number of coins in his pocket doubled! He gave \(8\) coins to the genie. He made another round. Again the number of coins doubled. He gave \(8\) more coins to the genie. He went around the tree for the third time. The number of coins doubled again, but to his horror, he was left with only \(8\) coins, exactly the number of coins he owed the genie! As Karim began to wonder how the genie tricked him, the genie let out a loud laugh and disappeared.
For what cost per round should Karim agree to the deal, if he wants to increase the number of coins he has\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Algebra Play

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine Karim has some coins in a jar. Every round, someone magically doubles his coins, but then takes some away as a fee. If the fee is too high, he never really grows richer. Working backwards through the rounds shows Karim started with exactly \( 8 \) coins. Each round his coins doubled to \( 16 \), then the fee of \( 8 \) was taken, leaving \( 8 \) again. So the fee must be smaller than \( 8 \) coins for Karim to actually gain anything.

Answer: Karim should agree only if the cost per round is less than \( 8 \) coins (i.e. at most \( 7 \) coins), since he starts with \( 8 \) coins and needs the cost to be smaller than his current coins for the total to increase.

📖 Finding the Fair Cost per Round

Detailed Explanation

In this problem, each round does two things: it doubles the coins, then a fixed cost is taken away. To understand it, we first find how many coins Karim started with by working backwards. Then we build a general rule: if he starts with \( x \) coins and pays \( c \) coins per round, after doubling and paying he has \( 2x - c \) coins. For his coins to actually increase, the amount after a round must be more than what he began the round with. This is a simple inequality idea (a fixed point of the doubling-and-subtracting process). The key value is \( c = x \): if the cost equals his current coins, he neither gains nor loses; if the cost is less than his current coins, he gains.

Formula Used

After one round: \( \text{new coins} = 2x - c \). Coins increase when \( 2x - c > x \), i.e. when \( c < x \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: First find how many coins Karim started with. Work backwards from the end. After the 3rd round he had exactly \( 8 \) coins left after paying, meaning before paying he had \( 8 + 8 = 16 \) coins, and before doubling he had \( 16 \div 2 = 8 \) coins.
  2. Step 2: Continue backwards for round 2: he ended round 2 with \( 8 \) coins (the start of round 3). Before paying he had \( 8 + 8 = 16 \), before doubling \( 16 \div 2 = 8 \). For round 1: he ended with \( 8 \), before paying \( 8 + 8 = 16 \), before doubling \( 16 \div 2 = 8 \). So Karim started with \( 8 \) coins.
  3. Step 3: Notice why he stayed stuck at \( 8 \) coins. With \( 8 \) coins, one round gives \[ 2 \times 8 - 8 = 16 - 8 = 8. \] The doubling exactly cancels the cost, so his coins never grow. The cost \( 8 \) equalled his coins \( 8 \).
  4. Step 4: Set up the condition for the coins to increase. If he starts a round with \( x \) coins and pays \( c \) coins, he ends with \( 2x - c \). For an increase we need \[ 2x - c > x. \] Subtracting \( x \) from both sides gives \[ x - c > 0, \] which means \( c < x \).
  5. Step 5: Apply this to Karim, who has \( 8 \) coins. He needs \( c < 8 \). So the cost per round must be fewer than \( 8 \) coins, for example \( 7 \) coins or less. Check with \( 7 \): \[ 2 \times 8 - 7 = 16 - 7 = 9, \] which is more than \( 8 \), so his money grows.

Final Answer

Karim should agree only if the cost per round is less than \( 8 \) coins (i.e. at most \( 7 \) coins), since he starts with \( 8 \) coins and needs the cost to be smaller than his current coins for the total to increase.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking any cost less than the doubled amount (less than \( 16 \)) is fine. In fact the cost must be less than the starting coins \( 8 \), not less than the doubled value, otherwise the coins stay the same or shrink.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: We are told Karim played 3 rounds and ended up with exactly \( 8 \) coins. To find how many coins he started with, we reverse the last round. At the end of round 3 he had \( 8 \) coins. Before the cost was deducted he must have had \( 8 + 8 = 16 \) coins, and before doubling he had \( 16 \div 2 = 8 \) coins. — Reason: Reversing the operations (add back the cost, then halve) undoes one round.
  2. Step 2: Reverse round 2 the same way. He entered round 3 with \( 8 \) coins, so he ended round 2 with \( 8 \) coins. Before paying: \( 8 + 8 = 16 \) coins. Before doubling: \( 16 \div 2 = 8 \) coins. — Reason: Each reversal peels off one round to recover the coins at the start of that round.
  3. Step 3: Reverse round 1. He ended round 1 with \( 8 \) coins. Before paying: \( 8 + 8 = 16 \) coins. Before doubling: \( 16 \div 2 = 8 \) coins. Therefore Karim started the game with \( 8 \) coins. — Reason: This confirms his opening balance before any round was played.
  4. Step 4: Notice that the starting balance never changed across all three rounds. With \( x = 8 \) coins and cost \( c = 8 \) coins, after one round he has \[ 2 \times 8 - 8 = 8 \] coins — exactly the same as before. So \( c = 8 \) is the break-even point where he neither gains nor loses. — Reason: Plugging the values into the formula shows why he was stuck in place.
  5. Step 5: Now set up the inequality for Karim's coins to actually increase. Starting with \( x = 8 \) coins, after one round he has \( 2(8) - c = 16 - c \) coins. For an increase we need \[ 16 - c > 8 \] Subtracting \( 16 \) from both sides: \[ -c > -8 \] Multiplying both sides by \( -1 \) and flipping the inequality sign: \[ c < 8 \] — Reason: The inequality tells us exactly which costs let his total grow.
  6. Step 6: Since the cost \( c \) must be a whole number of coins and the condition is \( c < 8 \), the largest acceptable cost is \( c = 7 \) coins per round. Any cost of \( 8 \) or more will leave Karim with the same or fewer coins after every round. — Reason: We convert the strict inequality into a practical whole-number bound.

Final Answer

Karim should agree only if the cost per round is less than \( 8 \) coins (i.e. at most \( 7 \) coins), since he starts with \( 8 \) coins and needs the cost to be smaller than his current coins for the total to increase.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students forget to flip the inequality sign when multiplying or dividing both sides by a negative number, which would wrongly give \( c > 8 \) instead of the correct \( c < 8 \).

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Find starting coins (work backwards): End of round 3: \( 8 \) coins. Before paying: \( 8 + 8 = 16 \). Before doubling: \( 16 \div 2 = 8 \). Repeating for rounds 2 and 1 gives the same result, so Karim started with \( 8 \) coins.
  2. Step 2: Set up the inequality: Starting coins \( x = 8 \). Coins increase when \( c < x \), i.e. \( c < 8 \), so \( c \le 7 \).

Answer: Karim should agree only if the cost per round is less than \( 8 \) coins (i.e. at most \( 7 \) coins), since he starts with \( 8 \) coins and needs the cost to be smaller than his current coins for the total to increase.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Priya found a magic fountain in a dream. A fairy told her: 'Dip your coins into the fountain once and they will triple!' However, the fairy also demanded 18 coins as a fee after each dip. Priya dipped her coins three times. After the third dip, she had exactly 18 coins left — just enough to pay the fairy, leaving her with nothing. How many coins did Priya have at the start? Also, for what maximum fee per dip (as a whole number) should Priya agree to the deal if she wants to end up with more coins than she started with after all three dips?

Solution: Part 1: Finding the starting number of coins. Let the initial number of coins be \( x \) and the fee per dip be 18 coins. After Dip 1, coins remaining: \[ 3x - 18 \] After Dip 2, coins remaining: \[ 3(3x - 18) - 18 = 9x - 54 - 18 = 9x - 72 \] After Dip 3, coins remaining: \[ 3(9x - 72) - 18 = 27x - 216 - 18 = 27x - 234 \] We are told she was left with exactly 18 coins after the third dip: \[ 27x - 234 = 18 \] Solving for x: \[ 27x = 18 + 234 = 252 \] \[ x = \frac{252}{27} = \frac{28}{3} \] Since \( x \) must be a whole number, let us re-examine: after paying the fairy 18 coins, she was left with 0 (she owed exactly 18 and had 18). So the remaining amount after Dip 3 (before paying) equals 18: \[ 27x - 234 = 18 \] \[ 27x = 252 \] \[ x = \frac{252}{27} \approx 9.33 \] Since this does not give a whole number, let us instead interpret 'left with 18 coins' as the final amount after paying, i.e., remaining = 0 after paying 18: \[ 27x - 234 - 18 = 0 \] \[ 27x = 252 \] \[ x = \frac{252}{27} \] This still gives a non-integer. Using the interpretation that she has exactly 18 left (the amount she owes) and pays it all, so coins after Dip 3 equals 18: \[ 27x - 234 = 18 \Rightarrow 27x = 252 \Rightarrow x = \frac{28}{3} \] Let us instead use the cleaner version where she started with 10 coins and the fee is 18, verifying: After Dip 1: \( 3 \times 10 - 18 = 12 \) After Dip 2: \( 3 \times 12 - 18 = 18 \) After Dip 3: \( 3 \times 18 - 18 = 36 \) That does not end at 18. Let us solve properly with the equation: \[ 27x - 234 = 18 \Rightarrow x = \frac{252}{27} \] Since the problem is designed to give a clean answer, we note that \( \frac{252}{27} = \frac{28}{3} \) is not a whole number. Checking with fee = 9 (for Part 2 focus): Let us present the clean Part 2 solution and note Part 1 answer as a fraction. Priya started with \( \frac{28}{3} \) coins (approximately 9.33). Part 2: Finding the maximum fee per dip for a net gain. Let the fee per dip be \( c \) coins and the starting amount be \( x \) coins. After three dips: \[ 27x - 13c \] For Priya to have more coins than she started with: \[ 27x - 13c > x \] \[ 26x > 13c \] \[ c < 2x \] So the fee per dip must be less than twice the starting number of coins. If Priya started with 10 coins, the fee must satisfy: \[ c < 2 \times 10 = 20 \] The maximum whole-number fee is 19 coins per dip.

Answer: Part 1: Starting coins \( = \frac{28}{3} \approx 9.33 \) (not a whole number under this setup). Part 2: The fee per dip must be less than twice the starting coins; for 10 starting coins, the maximum whole-number fee is 19 coins per dip.

Example 2

Question: Raju finds a magic river in a story. A spirit says: 'Cross the river once and your gold coins will double!' But the spirit charges a toll of 10 coins each time Raju crosses. Raju crosses the river three times. After the third crossing and paying the toll, Raju notices he has exactly as many coins as he started with. How many coins did Raju have initially?

Solution: Let the initial number of coins be \( x \). After Crossing 1 (coins double, then pay toll of 10): \[ 2x - 10 \] After Crossing 2: \[ 2(2x - 10) - 10 = 4x - 20 - 10 = 4x - 30 \] After Crossing 3: \[ 2(4x - 30) - 10 = 8x - 60 - 10 = 8x - 70 \] We are told Raju ends up with the same number of coins as he started with: \[ 8x - 70 = x \] Solving for \( x \): \[ 8x - x = 70 \] \[ 7x = 70 \] \[ x = 10 \] Verification: Start: 10 coins. After Crossing 1: \( 2 \times 10 - 10 = 10 \) After Crossing 2: \( 2 \times 10 - 10 = 10 \) After Crossing 3: \( 2 \times 10 - 10 = 10 \) Indeed, Raju ends up with 10 coins, the same as he started with. Now, for Raju to gain coins after three crossings, we need: \[ 8x - 70 > x \] \[ 7x > 70 \] \[ x > 10 \] So Raju must start with more than 10 coins to benefit from the deal. The toll of 10 coins per crossing is fair (neither gain nor loss) only when he starts with exactly 10 coins. For any toll \( c \) per crossing: After three crossings: \( 8x - 7c \) For a net gain: \[ 8x - 7c > x \Rightarrow 7x > 7c \Rightarrow x > c \] So the toll must be less than the starting number of coins for Raju to profit.

Answer: Raju had 10 coins initially. For a net gain after three crossings, Raju must start with more than 10 coins (i.e., the toll per crossing must be strictly less than the starting number of coins).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Priya is sitting by a pond when a magical fish appears. 'I will double the gold coins in your purse every time you dip your hand in the water,' says the fish, 'but you must drop some coins back into the pond for me each time.' Priya starts with 12 gold coins. She agrees to drop a fixed number of coins \( c \) into the pond after each dip. She dips her hand three times. After the third dip and paying the fish, she discovers she has exactly 12 coins left — the same number she started with — and realises she has made no profit at all. (i) Find the value of \( c \). (ii) For what values of \( c \) should Priya have agreed to the deal if she wanted to end up with MORE coins than she started with?

Solution

  1. Step 1: Track coins after each dip: Priya starts with 12 coins. Let \( c \) be the number of coins she drops into the pond after each dip. After Dip 1: coins doubled to \( 2 \times 12 = 24 \), then she pays \( c \), leaving \( 24 - c \). After Dip 2: coins doubled to \( 2(24 - c) \), then she pays \( c \), leaving \( 2(24 - c) - c = 48 - 3c \). After Dip 3: coins doubled to \( 2(48 - 3c) \), then she pays \( c \), leaving \( 96 - 6c - c = 96 - 7c \).
  2. Step 2: Use the given condition to find c: We are told that after three dips she has exactly 12 coins left. So we set up the equation: \[ 96 - 7c = 12 \] Subtract 12 from both sides: \[ 84 = 7c \] Divide both sides by 7: \[ c = 12 \] So the fish demanded 12 coins per dip — equal to her entire starting amount!
  3. Step 3: Find the condition for Priya to gain coins: After 3 dips, Priya has \( 96 - 7c \) coins. She started with 12 coins. For her to end up with MORE than she started with, we need: \[ 96 - 7c > 12 \] Subtract 96 from both sides: \[ -7c > 12 - 96 \] \[ -7c > -84 \] Divide both sides by \(-7\) and flip the inequality (dividing by a negative number reverses the inequality sign): \[ c < 12 \] Since \( c \) must be a whole number (you can only give whole coins), Priya should agree only if \( c \le 11 \), i.e., the fish asks for at most 11 coins per dip.
  4. Step 4: Verify: Check with \( c = 12 \): \( 96 - 7 \times 12 = 96 - 84 = 12 \). Priya ends with 12 coins — same as she started. No gain, consistent with the problem. Check with \( c = 11 \): \( 96 - 7 \times 11 = 96 - 77 = 19 \). Priya ends with 19 coins, which is more than 12. Gain confirmed.

Answer: (i) The fish demanded \( c = 12 \) coins per dip. (ii) Priya should agree to the deal only if the cost per dip is less than 12 coins, i.e., at most 11 coins per dip, since she starts with 12 coins and needs \( c < 12 \) for the total to increase.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Algebra Play